Alice Bertero1,2, Gergely David2, Adam Liska2, Alberto Galbusera2, Massimo Pasqualetti1,2, and Alessandro Gozzi2
1Department of Biology, Unit of Cell and Developmental Biology, University of Pisa, Pisa, Italy, 2Functional Neuroimaging Lab, Center for Neuroscience and Cognitive Systems, Istituto Italiano di Tecnologia, Rovereto, Italy
Synopsis
Autism spectrum disorder (ASD)
has been associated to reduced or aberrant functional brain connectivity
as measured with resting state fMRI (rsfMRI). However little is known on the
pathophysiological and genetic determinants underlying these alterations. Here we
show that mice recapitulating human chromosome 16p11.2
microdeletion, a trait associated with intellectual disability and high ASD
penetrance, exhibit reduced connectivity in prefrontal hubs of the mouse default
mode network, recapitulating a hallmark neuroimaging finding in ASD. These
findings establish a causal link between ASD-associated mutations and connectivity
alterations and identify a plausible macroscale substrate for the cognitive impairments
associated to 16p11.2 microdeletion. Background
Autism spectrum disorder (ASD) has been often associated to reduced or
aberrant functional brain connectivity as measured with resting state
functional Magnetic Resonance imaging (rsfMRI) [1]. However, great heterogeneity exists in the expression of these
alterations, and little is known on the pathophysiological and genetic etiology
of these deficits.
Mouse models harbouring
mutations with robust ASD-association can be used to probe causal relationships
between genetic variations and aberrant connectivity. By tightly controlling
motion and physiological parameters we recently demonstrated the possibility of
using rsfMRI to reliably map large-scale connectivity networks in the mouse
brain [2, 3]. The
approach led to the first identification of possible mouse homologues of the
human salience and default mode (DMN) networks in this species [2, 4].
Human chromosome 16p11.2
microdeletion, a genetic trait associated with mild intellectual disability, is
the most common gene copy number variation in autism, accounting for approximately
0.5–1% of all ASD cases. A mouse line harbouring a chromosomal deletion
syntenic to human 16p11.2 has been recently generated [5]. 16p11.2+/- mice exhibit cognitive impairments and mild
social deficits [5]. However, the macroscale substrates of the cognitive and social
impairments associated with 16p11.2 microdeletion remain elusive. We here used mouse
rsfMRI to probe whether 16p11.2 microdeletion results in macroscale functional
connectivity changes. Our approach permits to begin to establish causal
relations between connectivity impairments and specific ASD-related genetic
etiologies.
Methods
All
experiments were carried out in accordance with Italian regulations governing
animal welfare and protection. rsfMRI timeseries were acquired on N=11 16p11.2
+/- (heterozygous) adult male mice and N=12
control (16p11.2
+/+) littermates as previously described (6). Animals were imaged under shallow halothane anesthesia (0.7%) and artificial
ventilation. All experiments were performed on a 7.0 Tesla MRI scanner, using a
single-shot EPI sequence with TR/TE 1200/15 ms, flip angle 30°, matrix 100 ×
100, field of view 2 × 2 cm2, 24 coronal slices, slice thickness 0.50 mm and a
total rsfMRI acquisition time of 6 min. Image preprocessing: images were motion
corrected, spatially normalized, smoothed band-pass filtered and regression of
motion traces and the mean ventricular signal were applied. Seed based
correlation maps were computed using AFNI based on anatomical regions chosen a
priori from an anatomical atlas as previously described [6]
Results
Seed-correlation
mapping in the retrosplenial cortex (Rs), a key hub of the mouse DMN, revealed
reduced pre-frontal connectivity in 16p11.2
+/- mice compared to control
littermates. The effect was not seed-dependent and was apparent along the whole
retrosplenial-cingulate midline of the DMN (Fig. 1). We next probed insular-cingulate
rsfMRI connectivity, a network that recapitulates anatomical features of the
human salience network [2] (Fig. 2). 16p11.2
+/- mice showed reduced connectivity between
insular and anterior cingulate areas. Thalamo-prefrontal connectivity has also been
reported to be compromised in ASD [7]. We thus probed connectivity of ventral (infralimbic) PFC regions, as
these contain robust reciprocal projection with thalamic areas, and observed foci
of prefrontal-thalamic connectivity in 16p11.2+/- (Fig. 3). To
investigate the presence of alerations in axonal connectivity we also employed
rabies virus retrograde tracing of infralimbic regions [3] (Fig. 4) to which thalamic afferents project. The tracing result revealed
the presence of dense afferent neuronal clusters in mid thalamic regions of
both genotypes, suggesting that thalamo-cortical dysconnectivity observed does
not trivially reflect absence of projecting fibers. Homotopic inter-hemispheric
connectivity appeared to be broadly preserved in all the cortical and
subcortical regions assessed, including nuclei of the basal ganglia (p>0.10,
all ROIs). No genotype-dependent differences in anesthesia sensitivity were
detected as seen with a) halothane minimal alveolar concentration recordings
(p=0.18), b) mean arterial blood pressure mapping 17 (p=0.32), c) amplitude of
cortical BOLD signal fluctuations (p=0.31), thus arguing against a confounding
effect of anesthesia on the inter-strain connectivity differences.
Conclusions
We show that 16p11.2
+/- mice
exhibit long-range functional hypo-connectivity affecting prefrontal
integrative hubs of the “default-mode” and “salience” networks. The observed hypo-connectivity recapitulates hallmark neuroimaging
findings in ASD and serves as a possible macroscale substrate for the cognitive
deficits produced by 16p11.2 microdeletion. Our approach permits to begin to
establish causal relations between connectivity impairments and specific
ASD-related genetic etiologies and pave the way to the investigation of the neurobiological underpinnings of highly heterogeneous clinical connectivity
findings.
Acknowledgements
The study was funded by a grant from the Simons Foundation (SFARI 314688, A.G.).References
[1].
E. Anagnostou, M. Taylor, Molecular Autism 2, 4 (2011).
[2].
F. Sforazzini, A. J. Schwarz, A.
Galbusera, A. Bifone, A. Gozzi, NeuroImage
87, 403 (2014).
[3].
F. Sforazzini et al., Brain Struct Funct
1 (2014).
[4].
A. Liska, A. Galbusera, A. J. Schwarz,
A. Gozzi, NeuroImage 115, 281 (2015).
[5].
G. Horev et al., PNAS108, 17076 (2011).
[6].
Y. Zhan et al., Nat. Neurosci 17, 400 (2014).
[7]. A.
Nair, J. M. Treiber, D. K. Shukla, P. Shih, R. A. M++ller, Brain 136, 1942 (2013).