Jun Ma1, Carrie Wismans2, Zhipeng Cao1, Dennis W. J. Klomp2, Jannie P. Wijnen2, and William A. Grissom1,3
1Vanderbilt University Institute of Imaging Science, Nashville, TN, United States, 2Department of Radiology, University Medical Centre Utrecht, Utrecht, Netherlands, 3Biomedical Engineering, Vanderbilt University, Nashville, TN, United States
Synopsis
At ultra-high
field (7T and above), the increased SNR can be used to significantly improve MRSI
spatial resolution, but scan time is a challenge with large acquisition
matrixes, so time-efficient water signal suppression is critical. However, at
ultra-high field, B1+ and B0 inhomogeneities
degrade the performance of time-efficient CHESS water suppression strategies. To
address this, we propose to replace conventional spectrally-selective pulses
with subject-tailored spiral in-out spectral-spatial (SPSP) saturation pulses
that are designed using subject-specific B1+ and B0 maps. The pulses
were validated in in vivo experiments.Introduction
Water
signal suppression is critical for magnetic resonance spectroscopic imaging
(MRSI). At ultra-high field (7T and above), the increased SNR can be used to
significantly improve MRSI spatial resolution, but acquisition matrixes of
32x32 or higher only have acceptable measurement times when the TR is short
(<300ms). The most time-efficient
pulse sequence-based water signal suppression methods are based on
pre-saturation using 90 degree excitation pulses followed by spoiling gradients
(CHESS)
1,2,3. However, at ultra-high field, B1
+ and B0
inhomogeneities degrade the performance of the pulses used by these methods. To
address this, we propose to replace conventional spectrally-selective pulses
with subject-tailored spiral in-out spectral-spatial (SPSP) saturation pulses
4 that are designed using subject-specific B1
+ and B0 maps.
Methods
Design Specifications The pulses comprise a train of identical tailored spiral
in-out spatial subpulses that are weighted by a spectral envelope. The design targeted:
Maximum total duration 26ms; Spectral FOV = 5.2 ppm (1550Hz) (so that passband
replicas fell on either side of the metabolites of interest); 1 ppm wide passband
(water-band) and transition band widths (300Hz); Stopband (metabolite-band)
width 4.2 ppm (1250 Hz). The spectral FOV dictated a maximum spatial subpulse duration
of 0.645 ms.
Spatial Pulse Design The 0.645 ms spatial subpulses were first designed to
produce a uniform flip angle pattern over the brain slice of interest. The 0.645
ms spiral in-out trajectories had FOV 10 cm and resolution 3.2 cm. Prior to
pulse design the waveforms were preemphasized5 and the final
measured trajectory was used for design. Pulses were
designed on a 32x32 spatial grid using a power-regularized matrix pseudoinverse6 that was alternated with a target phase pattern update to implement a magnitude
least-squares7
Spectral Pulse Design A minimum-phase spectral envelope with a
time-bandwidth product of 5.72 was then designed using SLR8. Root-flipping
based on an exhaustive search of passband root-flip combinations was applied to
reduce the peak amplitude of the pulses while maintaining their excitation
amplitude profile9. The final pulse was constructed by replicating
the spatial subpulse 41 times and weighting each replica by its position in the
spectral envelope.
Experiments The pulses were implemented on a Philips 7T
Achieva scanner (Philips Healthcare, Cleveland, Ohio, USA) and used to scan healthy
subjects. To image the pulses’ saturation patterns they were played immediately
before a gradient spoiler and the excitation pulse of a 2D spin echo sequence. The
frequency of the pulses was varied during imaging. The pattern of a spectral
pulse with the same duration and spectral characteristics was also imaged, as
well as a zero pulse for dividing out receive sensitivities and other signal
variations. A pulse-acquire MRSI experiment was performed using a crusher coil for
lipid suppression at the skull10, and a CHESS sequence in which three
spectral pulses were replaced by the tailored RF pulses was used for water
suppression. That sequence had parameters: TR 340ms, TE 2.5ms, flip angle 30
degrees, matrix 18 x 18, 3 averages, acquisition time 6:21 min.
Results
The
total pulse design time (including spatial subpulse and spectral envelope
designs) was 0.4 seconds on a Core i7 laptop. Root-flipping the spectral
envelope reduced peak B1+
demand by 33% compared to the initial spectral envelope (Fig.1). Figure 2 shows
a simulated comparison of spiral in and spiral in-out subpulses. The spiral in trajectory
achieves ~2x finer resolution than the spiral in-out trajectory (Fig. 2A), but
the spiral in-out pulse has 47% lower peak amplitude and 40% lower SAR since it
visits the center of k-space twice (Fig. 2B). Figure 2C shows that the spiral
in-out subpulse is also more robust to off-resonance, since small off-resonance
effects cancel out in redundant spiral in-out readouts
11. Figure 3
shows that gradient preemphasis converged to triangular-shaped waveforms which
produced measurements that closely matched the desired waveforms. The minimum
TR of the in vivo experiment with the saturation sequence using a single pulse
was 53 ms. In the passband, the mean normalized residual signal was 0.53 for
the conventional spectral RF, and 0.16 for the tailored pulse (3.3x lower)
(Fig.4). Figure 5 shows that MR spectra with reasonable quality were obtained using
tailored RF pulses for water suppression. In that data, residual water signal
was removed by fitting unsuppressed data to the water-suppressed data.
Discussion and Conclusions
We
have proposed and validated spiral in-out spectral-spatial tailored RF pulses for
water suppression in MRSI measurements. Combining this fast water suppression technique
with a crusher coil for lipid suppression will enable artifact-free ultra-high
resolution MRSI in the brain within 10 min acquisition times.
Acknowledgements
This
work was supported by NIH Grant R01 EB016695.References
1. Haase, A., et
al. "1H NMR chemical shift selective (CHESS) imaging." Physics in medicine and biology 30.4 (1985): 341.
2. Ogg, Robert J.,
R. B. Kingsley, and June S. Taylor. "WET, a T 1-and B 1-insensitive
water-suppression method for in vivo localized 1 H NMR spectroscopy." Journal of Magnetic Resonance,
Series B 104.1 (1994): 1-10.
3. Tkác, I., Z.
Starcuk, I-Y. Choi, and R. Gruetter. "In vivo 1H NMR spectroscopy of rat
brain at 1 ms echo time." Magnetic
Resonance in Medicine 41, no.
EPFL-ARTICLE-177519 (1999): 649-656.
4. Morrell, Glen,
and Albert Macovski. "Three-dimensional
spectral-spatial excitation." Magnetic
resonance in medicine 37.3
(1997): 378-386.
5. Harkins, Kevin
D., Mark D. Does, and William A. Grissom. "Iterative method for predistortion
of MRI gradient waveforms." Medical
Imaging, IEEE Transactions on 33.8
(2014): 1641-1647.
6. Grissom,
William, et al. "Spatial domain method for the design of RF pulses in
multicoil parallel excitation." Magnetic
resonance in medicine 56.3 (2006):
620-629.
7. Setsompop, K.,
et al. "Magnitude least squares optimization for parallel radio frequency
excitation design demonstrated at 7 Tesla with eight channels."Magnetic
Resonance in Medicine 59.4
(2008): 908-915.
8. Pauly, John, et
al. "Parameter relations for the Shinnar-Le Roux selective excitation
pulse design algorithm [NMR imaging]." Medical
Imaging, IEEE Transactions on 10.1
(1991): 53-65.
9. Pickup, Stephen,
and Xiaoning Ding. "Pulses with fixed magnitude and variable phase
response profiles." Magnetic
resonance in medicine 33.5
(1995): 648-655.
10. Boer, Vincent
O., et al. "Lipid suppression for brain MRI and MRSI by means of a
dedicated crusher coil." Magnetic
Resonance in Medicine 73.6
(2015): 2062-2068.
11. Fielden, Samuel
W., and Craig H. Meyer. "A simple acquisition strategy to avoid off-resonance blurring in spiral imaging with redundant spiral-in/out k-space trajectories." Magnetic Resonance in Medicine 73.2 (2015): 704-710.