Synopsis
3He and
129Xe ventilation and diffusion-weighted MR images were acquired at
1.5T in healthy volunteers and, at multiple time-points, in COPD patients in
order to compare the functional sensitivity and assess the repeatability of
MR-derived measures of ventilated volume (VV%) and apparent diffusion
coefficient (ADC) from each of the two gases. ADC values from both nuclei exhibited
excellent agreement and significant correlations with pulmonary function tests
(PFTs) (p<0.001), whilst VV% values were less comparable. ADC and VV%
metrics derived from both nuclei were also shown to be repeatable, with coefficient of variation
values similar to those of PFTs.Purpose
Hyperpolarised gas MRI with
3He
and
129Xe has been established as a functional tool to image lung
ventilation and detect lung microstructural changes [1]. A recent comparison of
ventilation imaging and apparent diffusion coefficient (ADC) mapping with
3He
and
129Xe at 3T [2] demonstrated that comparable ventilation and
microstructural information can be obtained from the two gases. In addition,
3He
ADC MRI has been shown to be highly repeatable in healthy volunteers and COPD
patients [3]. However, comparison of the functional sensitivity of
3He
and
129Xe lung MRI has not been performed to date at 1.5T, and the
repeatability of ADC mapping MRI with
129Xe is yet to be adequately assessed.
In this work,
3He and
129Xe ventilation and
diffusion-weighted MR images were acquired at 1.5T in healthy volunteers and,
at multiple time-points, in COPD patients in order to compare the functional
sensitivity and assess the repeatability of MR-derived measures of ventilated
volume and lung microstructure from each of the two gases.
Methods
Nine healthy volunteers (with no history of lung disease) and five COPD
patients were recruited for hyperpolarised
3He and
129Xe
gas MR imaging. 2D
3He and
129Xe diffusion-weighted MR
images (see e.g. [4]) were acquired for all subjects and ADC maps were
calculated from the first (b=0s/cm
2) and second diffusion
interleaves (
3He b=1.6s/cm
2,
129Xe b=8.0s/cm
2).
In COPD patients, 3D steady-state free-precession (SSFP) images of lung
ventilation were acquired with both gases using the parameters described in
[5,6], and ventilation volume percentages (VV%) were calculated as described
previously [5]. The whole imaging protocol was repeated in the COPD patients on
three additional scan sessions (same-day, next-day and after 2 weeks) to assess
the repeatability of
3He and
129Xe MR-derived measures of
ventilated volume and lung microstructure.
Measurements of VV% and ADC derived from
3He and
129Xe
MRI were compared to evaluate the relative functional sensitivity of the two
gases to obstructive lung disease and emphysematous microstructural changes.
These metrics were also compared to pulmonary function tests (PFTs), including
the diffusing capacity of carbon monoxide (TL
CO), forced expiratory
volume in 1 second (FEV
1), and the ratio of FEV
1 to
forced vital capacity (FVC) (FEV
1/FVC), acquired on the same day as
each scan. The coefficient of variation (CoV) of each MR and PFT parameter was
calculated to assess repeatability. For COPD patients, the mean values and
standard deviations over all scan sessions were used for comparisons.
Results and Discussion
As expected, MR images from both
nuclei highlighted significant ventilation abnormalities in COPD subjects and higher
global mean ADC values compared to volunteers (two-tailed t-test, p<0.001,
Figure 1). VV% values were observed to be larger on average for
3He
than
129Xe (p<0.001), similar to previous observations [7], reflecting
the ability of
3He to penetrate less well-ventilated lung by virtue
of its higher diffusion coefficient. A strong positive correlation between
3He
and
129Xe ADC values was observed in healthy volunteers and COPD
patients (Spearman’s correlation coefficient 0.982, p<0.001, Figure 2a). ADC
values derived from both gases exhibited significant correlations with PFTs
(Table 1), most notably TL
CO, which is in good agreement with
previous findings [2,3]. Comparing VV% measurements and PFTs, only
3He
VV% exhibited a significant correlation with FEV
1/FVC (p<0.05),
and the relationship between
3He and
129Xe derived VV%
values was not significant (Figure 2b). The lack of observed significant correlation
between VV% values of the two gases and other PFT measures can be attributed to
a low number of data-points (n=5) and the absence of comparative healthy
volunteer data.
ADC metrics of both gases were
found to be highly repeatable, with mean coefficient of variation (CoV) values
(<3%) comparable to or less than those of the PFT results (Table 2). CoV
values were slightly higher for VV% measures – in particular for
129Xe,
likely due to difficulty in manual segmentation of ventilation images and/or
variability in
129Xe polarisation levels. However the mean
3He
and
129Xe VV% CoV values over all subjects were still <5% and
<15%, respectively, indicating good intra-subject repeatability.
Conclusion
Preliminary experimental validation of
hyperpolarised
3He and
129Xe MR ventilation imaging and ADC
mapping has been demonstrated at 1.5T in COPD patients and healthy volunteers. ADC
values from both nuclei exhibited excellent agreement and significant
correlations with PFT results, whilst corresponding VV% values were not as
comparable due to small sample sizes. ADC and VV% metrics derived from both
nuclei were repeatable, paving the way to increased use of
129Xe as
a more readily-available, cost-effective alternative to
3He for
clinical lung imaging studies.
Acknowledgements
No acknowledgement found.References
[1] Fain, S. B. et al., J Magn
Reson Imaging, 25(5):910-23 (2007). [2] Kirby, M. et al., Radiology,
265:600-10 (2012).
[3] Diaz, S. et al., J Magn Reson
Imaging, 27(4):763-70 (2008).
[4] Parra-Robles, J. et al., Magn
Reson Med, 67:322-5 (2012).
[5] Horn, F. C. et al., NMR in
Biomed, 27(12):1461-7 (2014).
[6] Stewart, N. J. et al., Magn
Reson Med, 74:346-352 (2015).
[7] Kirby, M. et al., J Appl
Physiol, 114:707-15 (2013).