Trisha Roy1,2, Garry Liu1, Noor Shaikh1, Kevan Anderson1, Nicolas Yak1, Xiuling Qi1, Andrew Dueck1,2, and Graham Wright1,3
1Schulich Heart Program and the Sunnybrook Research Institute, Sunnybrook Health Sciences Centre, Toronto, ON, Canada, 2Division of Vascular Surgery, University of Toronto, Toronto, Canada, 3Department of Medical Biophysics, University of Toronto, Toronto, Canada
Synopsis
Percutaneous vascular
interventions (PVI) for treating peripheral arterial disease (PAD) have poor
outcomes with high re-intervention and failure rates. Not all lesions are
amenable to PVI, but predicting failure is difficult. While CT can identify
heavily calcified lesions, current imaging offers limited differentiation
between hard and soft PAD plaques, which impacts procedural success. This study
demonstrates the feasibility of using MRI biomarkers to characterize plaque
components in ex-vivo human peripheral arteries with histologic and microCT
validation. We demonstrate that significantly higher puncture forces are
required to cross non-calcified “hard” chronic total occlusions (CTOs) compared
to “soft” CTOs, as classified by these MRI biomarkers.Target Audience
MR vascular imaging researchers,
interventional radiologists, interventional cardiologists, vascular surgeons
Purpose
Many of the challenges associated with planning and performing
lower-extremity percutaneous vascular interventions (PVI) are associated with
limited visualization. X-ray fluoroscopy does not allow the visualization of
the vessel wall or plaque components. This information may assist with
predicting the success of an intervention, navigation within an occlusion, and
wire/device selection.
We hypothesize that MRI can characterize peripheral arterial disease
(PAD) plaque components and their associated mechanical properties.
Understanding PAD plaque composition may help in planning and performing PVI by
identifying soft lesion components to facilitate guide wire passage. We aim to
develop and validate MRI methods for characterizing PAD lesions to ultimately
use this information to plan PVI for patients.
Methods
MRI was performed on 31 excised human peripheral arterial plaques from 6
patients who underwent amputation. Each sample was imaged at 7 Tesla at high
resolution (75μm3 voxels) to produce 3D T2-weighted (T2W) and Ultrashort
Echo Time (UTE) images. For T2W imaging, a fast spin-echo sequence with an
echo-train length of 8 and an effective TE of 47 ms was used. For UTE imaging,
a gradient-echo radial sequence with a TE of 20μs was used. 15 samples were studied
to validate MR biomarkers for the following components (T2W, UTE): lumen (∅,∅), fat (+, ≈), thrombus (∅, +), loose fibrous tissue (≈, ≈), dense fibrous tissue/collagen
(∅,≈), and calcium (∅,-), where ∅ means no signal, and -,≈,+
mean hypo-, iso-, an hyper-intense versus muscle respectively. Tissue classes were validated with microCT and histology.
The
remaining 16 lesions were all chronic total occlusions (CTOs) and were used for
guide wire force-displacement testing. CTOs with MR imaging signatures
corresponding to fat, thrombus or those with microchannels were classified as “soft”.
CTOs with loose fibrous tissue imaging signatures were classified as
“intermediate”. CTOs with dense fibrous tissue/collagen MR imaging signatures were
classified as “hard”. Guide wire crossing studies were performed on each
sample. A 2kg load cell advanced the back end of a 0.035” Lunderquist® Extra Stiff (Cook Medical)
guide wire at a fixed displacement rate of 0.05mm/s through the CTO, and the
forces required to cross the lesion were measured.
Results
MRI biomarkers for “hard”, “intermediate” and “soft” CTOs correlated with
guide wire force-displacement testing. Though densely calcified plaques were
studied for sequence validation (Figure 1), there were no densely calcified CTOs
in the subset of samples that underwent force-displacement testing. Preliminary
testing of densely calcified plaques failed mechanical testing likely because
they required puncture forces greater than 20N (the upper limit of our current
experimental set-up). Non-calcified hard CTOs (n=2) required an average
puncture force of 1.92N ± 0.83 (Figures 2
and 3). Intermediate CTOs (n=10) required an average puncture force of 0.36N ± 0.21. Soft CTOs (n=4) required an average puncture force of 0.05N ± 0.02. There was a statistically significant
difference between groups as determined by one-way ANOVA (F(2,13) =
30.407, P <.05).
Discussion and Conclusion
PVI offers an attractive, minimally invasive approach to treating PAD, but
not all lesions are amenable to PVI. Densely calcified lesions are resistant to
dilatation, have higher failure and complication rates
1 with PVI and
are typically recommended for bypass surgery
2. Though current
clinical imaging modalities can characterize calcium well, they offer limited
visualization of non-calcified hard plaques, which also influence procedural
success
3. The results of this study demonstrate the potential of using
high-resolution MRI to differentiate densely calcified plaques, non-calcified
hard plaques and soft plaques to determine ease of guide wire crossing. This study
provides a foundation for future in-vivo studies on predicting the lesion
crossability of various PAD plaque types from MRI data sets of patients who
undergo PVI.
Acknowledgements
This
study was supported by funds from the Canadian Institutes of Health Research.References
1.
Das T, Mustapha J, Indes Jeffrey, et al. The CONFIRM
series, a prospective multicenter registry. Catheter Cardiovasc Interv.
2014:83(10):115-22.
2.
Strauss BH, Osherov AB, Radhakrishnan S, et al.
Collagenase Total Occlusion-1 (CTO-1) trial. Circulation. 2012;125(3):522-528.
3.
TASC Steering Committee*. A supplement to the
inter-society consensus for the management of peripheral arterial disease (TASC
II). J Endovasc Ther. 2015;22(5):663-677.