Synopsis
Peripheral vascular
function can be interrogated by measuring recovery dynamics following induced
ischemia. In this study, 136 patients with peripheral artery disease were
randomized into supervised exercise rehabilitation (SER) or standard medical
care (SMC). Each patient’s leg was scanned before and after the intervention
period. MRI data were acquired throughout an ischemia-reperfusion paradigm with
PIVOT, a method to simultaneously and dynamically measure perfusion, venous
oxygen saturation, and skeletal muscle T2*. Patients randomized to
SER had a significant increase in peak perfusion from baseline to follow-up
when averaged across the entire cross-section of the leg and in the peroneus
muscle. Introduction
Peripheral artery
disease (PAD), generally a manifestation of atherosclerosis in vessels
supplying the lower limbs, is diagnosed based on a reduction in the ratio of
blood pressures measured in the ankle and brachial artery, known as the
ankle-brachial index (ABI)
1. An ABI less than 0.9 signifies the
presence of macrovascular stenoses, but does not specify spatial location, is
not sensitive to microvascular impairment, and does not reflect improvements
due to pharmacologic or exercise therapy
2,3.
Recent studies suggest
that functional deficits present in the vasculature of patients with PAD may be
detected through dynamic imaging studies
4-7. Similar to cardiac
stress testing, peripheral vascular function is interrogated by measuring the
kinetics of recovery following induced ischemia (during reactive hyperemia),
which is blunted and delayed in patients with PAD compared
to their healthy peers. This has been reported from independent studies
measuring muscle perfusion
4, dynamics of venous oxygen saturation
(SvO
2)
5, or relative changes in skeletal muscle T
2*
6,
which is related to tissue oxygenation and perfusion, and more recently using
PIVOT, a combined method to measure perfusion, SvO
2, and T
2*
simultaneously
8. The purpose of this study was to evaluate whether a
supervised exercise intervention resulted in changes in MRI-measured vascular
function.
Methods
136 patients (86 male, 68±8
years old) with PAD were recruited to participate in the study and underwent one
screening visit and two testing visits (study design shown in
Figure 1).
The treadmill-walking test employed the Gardner protocol
9, which
requires patients to walk on a treadmill at 2 mph initially with 0% incline and
the incline is increased by 2% every 2 minutes. Patients indicate when they
first experience pain (claudication onset time, COT), and when the pain limits
their ability to walk (peak walking time, PWT). The MRI protocol consisted of
dynamic imaging using PIVOT
10 (see
Figure 2 for pulse
sequence diagram) continuously throughout one minute of baseline, five minutes
of proximal arterial occlusion, and six minutes of post-ischemic recovery. Data
were acquired with an 8-ch Tx/Rx knee coil at 3T. Ischemia was induced by
inflating a cuff around the thigh to 75 mmHg above the systolic blood pressure. All PIVOT measures were quantified with 2-second
temporal resolution. Perfusion was calculated in regions of interest (ROIs) in
the gastrocnemius, soleus, peroneus, and tibialis anterior muscles, and was
averaged across all ROIs (leg) and peak hyperemic flow (PHF) and time to peak
perfusion (TTP
perf) were recorded. SvO
2 was measured in
the larger posterior tibial vein, and washout time (time to minimum SvO
2)
and upslope (maximum slope of recovery) were recorded. T
2* was
quantified in the soleus, normalized to the average baseline value, and the
relative T
2*
max and time to peak T
2* (TTP
T2*)
were recorded. Example images and time courses are shown in
Figure 3. Paired
t-tests were used to assess the change from baseline to follow-up, and the
Holm-Bonferroni correction was applied to maintain a family-wise error rate of
0.05.
Results
112/136 patients
returned for their follow-up visit 119±28
days after the baseline visit (19 lost to follow-up, 5 presently enrolled).
From the initial testing visit, significant correlations were detected between
ABI and reactive hyperemia response time across all patients, however no
correlation was observed between ABI and reactive hyperemia response magnitude
or between ABI and indices of functional disease impairment measured by
treadmill-walking test (
Figure 4). From baseline to follow-up, COT and
PWT significantly increased in the SER group (paired
t-test, p<0.0001 for both). COT significantly increased in the
SMC group as well (paired
t-test, p<0.01). From the MRI data, no significant
differences were detected between the SER and SMC groups at baseline or
follow-up for any metric. In the SER group, the change in peak perfusion
between baseline and follow-up significantly increased in the peroneus
(p<0.05) and when averaged across the whole leg (p<0.05) (
Figure 5).
Discussion & Conclusion
This preliminary analysis showed that patients
enrolled in a supervised exercise intervention had a significant increase in
peak perfusion in the peroneus and across the entire cross-section of the leg.
This response may be attributed to increased angiogenesis induced by exercise. Moreover,
since the reactive hyperemia response time is highly correlated with ABI as
seen in
Figure 4 (which is primarily a marker of macrovascular disease),
it would make sense that changes in response time are not observed as the
stenoses are relatively fixed. Future analyses will explore whether changes in
the MRI-measures of vascular function are correlated with changes in
physiologic response as measured by the treadmill-walking tests, blood markers
of angiogenesis, and patient quality of life questionnaires.
Acknowledgements
This work was supported by an award from the American Heart
Association and NIH Grants R01 HL075649 and HL109545.References
[1] Hirsch, et al. JAMA
2001; [2] Mohler, et al. Vasc Med 2001; [3] Murphy, et al. Circ 2012; [4] Wu,
et al. JACC 2009; [5] Langham, et al. JCMR 2013; [6] Ledermann, et al. Circ 2006; [7] Potthast, et al. Gefäße 2009; [8] Englund, et al. Circ Cardiovasc Imaging 2015; [9] Gardner, et al. Med Sci Sports Exerc 1991; [10] Englund, et al. JCMR
2013; [11] Raynaud, et al. MRM 2001;
[12] Fernandez-Seara, et al. MRM 2006.