Synopsis
We
used a hybrid radial-Cartesian 3D EPI trajectory with a golden ratio based
angle update to perform retrospective motion correction in severely motion
corrupted fMRI data. Motion estimates were based on high temporal resolution image
timeseries and and k-space based estimates. The calculated rotations and
translations were corrected in k-space prior to the final
reconstruction, allowing the correction of both inter- and intra-volume motion
artifacts. This approach is self-navigated, requires no additional hardware and
is suitable for correction in fast fMRI acquisition. Purpose
To present a novel 3D trajectory and associated image reconstruction
that enables k-space correction of severe motion at high temporal resolution,
with application to functional MRI.
Introduction
3D EPI has a number of potential benefits for high-resolution fMRI,
including high SNR
1, acceleration along multiple dimensions and the ability to
resolve thin slices. However, whole brain acquisitions typically need multiple
seconds to sample a full 3D k-space, which make them susceptible to temporal
fluctuations such as motion and physiological noise. Retrospective corrections for
motion
2 and
physiological noise
3 can mitigate these effects, but these methods cannot
correct for intra-volume fluctuations. Our recently proposed acquisition scheme
enables correction of these artefacts, using a hybrid radial-Cartesian readout
4-6 in which k
xy-k
z EPI “blades” are rotated in a golden
ratio angle scheme
7 about the k
z-axis (Fig. 1a). This scheme
ensures near-uniform angular coverage of k-space for an arbitrary number of
blades, which allows flexible post-acquisition definition of spatial and
temporal resolution (Fig. 1b). To exploit this property for motion and physiological
noise correction, we first reconstruct a low-spatial/high-temporal resolution timeseries
to calculate motion estimates and respiration-induced B
0 drift. These
estimates are fed into the second stage, in which motion and respiration fluctuations
are corrected in k-space, and used to reconstruct the final
timeseries at high-spatial/moderate-temporal resolution.
Methods
Acquisition: Data was acquired at 3T
on 3 healthy volunteers. Two experiments with deliberate subject motion were
performed: (1) Set motion: subjects visually queued to perform 6 different
motions (x/y/z translations, x/y/z rotations) during a 130 second scan. (2) Natural
motion: subjects asked to be fidgety (e.g. move their legs or cough) during a 300
second task fMRI experiment with visual stimulus (30s ON/OFF 8Hz checkerboard) and
simultaneous bilateral finger tapping. All acquisitions used TR/TE=50/25ms,
blade EPI matrix 100x76, 2mm isotropic, R=2 along blade PE.
General reconstruction information: Image
reconstruction was performed in MATLAB. Parallel imaging was performed using
the GRAPPA and SPIRiT8 algorithms.
Correction: The motion and 0-order
phase offset are first estimated (stage 1) and subsequently corrected in
k-space (stage 2) prior to the final reconstruction.
Stage 1: Rigid
body motion was estimated in image-space from 10-blade timeseries (TRvol =
0.5s), using MCFLIRT (FSL). Shifts in the z-direction (nominally blade PE
direction) were estimated blade-by-blade (TR=0.05s) in the centre of k-space by
fitting a linear and 0-order phase changes.
Stage 2: To
correct for rotations, k-space coordinates were rotated accordingly and shifts
were removed by subtracting the corresponding phase ramps and the phase offset
from k-space.
Final reconstruction and analysis: Final
reconstructions were performed using 50 blades (TRvol = 2.5s)
corresponding to a total under-sampling factor of ~6 (2x3.14). Before fMRI
analysis, rigid body motion correction (MCFLIRT) was performed across all
datasets (to assess the advantage of our method over standard retrospective
rigid body motion correction). fMRI
analysis was performed in FEAT (FSL) using no temporal filtering, spatial smoothing
or pre-whitening.
Results
Motion
estimates and residual motion after correction are displayed for a
representative subject in Figs. 2-3. Subject motion was removed very accurately
for translations and rotations. Uncorrected datasets contain volumes with
severe intra-volume inconsistency artifacts (Fig. 2, bottom), which are
significantly reduced in the corrected timeseries. Voxel-wise mean temporal
variance was reduced by 16/38/45% for subjects 1-3 for set motions and 42/25 %
for subjects 2/3 for natural motion scans. The natural motion scan of subject 1
was excluded because of extreme motion (>20mm/>10deg). The number of
voxels with activation (z≥2.3) in visual cortex ROIs increased by 21/25% for
subjects 2/3 and by 41/42% in the motor cortex. Average z-stats increased by
9/3% for subjects 2/3 in the visual cortex and 9/1% in the motor cortex. Example
variance and z-stat maps are shown in Fig. 4. In
the presence of extreme and very rapid motion residual artifact is still
observed (Fig. 5).
Discussion
We have
demonstrated the motion correction capabilities of hybrid radial-Cartesian 3D
EPI even in the presence of severe motion. The approach requires no designated
hardware, and is self-navigated. This makes the approach suitable for fMRI, where the TR needs to be short and re-acquisition is
not possible. The remaining artifacts in some volumes after correction likely
come from estimating motion over 0.5s intervals, although residual error might
also come from variation in distortion and coil sensitivity, which we cannot
account for. In future work we aim to refine the temporal resolution of motion
estimates using fewer blades at a time (e.g. 2-3 blades, enabling 0.1-0.15s
resolution) to estimate more accurate x/y shifts and rotations.
Acknowledgements
M. Chiew and K.L. Miller have contributed equivalently to this work. Funding sources: SNSF (N. Graedel), EPSRC (M. Chiew), Wellcome Trust (K. Miller).References
[1] Poser, B. A., Koopmans, P. J., Witzel, T., Wald, L. L., & Barth, M. (2010). Three dimensional echo-planar imaging at 7 Tesla. Neuroimage, 51(1), 261–266.
[2] Jenkinson,
M., Bannister, P., Brady, J. M. and Smith, S. M. (2002) Improved Optimisation for the
Robust and Accurate Linear Registration and Motion Correction of Brain Images.
NeuroImage, 17(2), 825-841.
[3] Glover, G. H., Li T., & Ress D. (2000). Image-based method for retrospective correction of physiological motion effects in fMRI: RETROICOR., 44(1), 162–167.
[4] McNab, J.
A., Gallichan, D., & Miller, K. L. (2010). 3D steady-state
diffusion-weighted imaging with trajectory using radially batched internal
navigator echoes (TURBINE). Magnetic Resonance in Medicine, 63(1), 235–242.
[5] Ehses et
al., Proceedings of the 22nd Annual Meeting of ISMRM (2014)
[6] Graedel et
al., Proceedings of the 23rd Annual Meeting of ISMRM (2015)
[7] Winkelmann,
S., Schaeffter, T., Koehler, T., Eggers, H., & Dössel, O. (2007). An
Optimal Radial Profile Order Based on the Golden Ratio for Time-Resolved MRI.
IEEE Transactions on Medical Imaging, 26(1), 68–76.
[8] Lustig,
M., & Pauly, J. M. (2010). SPIRiT: Iterative self-consistent parallel
imaging reconstruction from arbitrary k-space., 64(2), 457–471.