Florian Knoll1, Martin Holler2, Thomas Koesters1, Martijn Cloos1, Ricardo Otazo1, Kristian Bredies2, and Daniel K Sodickson1
1Center for Advanced Imaging Innovation and Research (CAI2R) and Bernard and Irene Schwartz Center for Biomedical Imaging, Department of Radiology, NYU School of Medicine, New York, NY, United States, 2Mathematics and Scientific Computing, University of Graz, Graz, Austria
Synopsis
A
typical clinical imaging protocol covers a large number of different
image contrasts and, in the era of multi-modality systems, even
different imaging modalities. While the resulting datasets share a
substantial amount of structural information, they consist of
fundamentally different contrasts and signal values and show unique
features and image content. We propose a reconstruction framework
based on nuclear-norm second-order Total Generalized Variation that
exploits structural similarity both between different contrasts and
modalities while still being flexible with respect to signal
intensity and unique features. Numerical simulations and in vivo
MR-Fingerprinting experiments demonstrate improved PET resolution and
improved depiction of quantitative values. The proposed approach
allows a 6 minute whole brain coverage exam that provides both
quantitative PET and MR-relaxation parameters.Purpose
A
typical clinical imaging protocol covers a large number of different
image contrasts and, in the age of multi-modality systems, even
different imaging modalities. The standard approach of separate data
acquisition and reconstruction is inefficient and wasteful, given the
substantial amount of anatomical correlations between these datasets.
On the other hand, given the different imaging physics and contrast
mechanisms, each subset can also contain unique features which may be
missing or appear differently in others. In this work, we propose a generalized
reconstruction framework for simultaneous reconstruction of images from different
contrasts and modalities that takes advantage of the inherent
redundancies while ensuring that the unique features and signal
values of each individual image data set are preserved. Going beyond
mere relative contrast variations, we show that PET and
MR-Fingerprinting (MRF) [1] can jointly be reconstructed while
preserving the quantitative nature of the underlying methods.
Theory
In
the proposed framework, we regard images from
different contrasts and modalities as different channels of
a multi-channel image $$$u=(u_i)_{i=1}^{n}$$$, each $$$u_i$$$
corresponding to one contrast or modality. Reconstruction is achieved by solving the convex optimization problem:
$$\min_{u=(u_i)_{i=1}^{n}}\text{TGV}_{\alpha}^2(u)+\sum_{i=1}^n\lambda_iD(u_i,d_i),$$
where
$$$D(u_i,d_i)$$$ is the data fidelity for data $$$d_i$$$. It is given either as $$$D(u_i,d_i)=\left\|E_iu_i-d_i\right\|_2^2$$$ for MR, $$$E_i$$$ being the
MR forward operator, or $$$D(u_i,d_i)=\int\left(Au_i-d_i\log(Au_i
)\right)$$$ for PET, $$$A$$$ being the PET forward operator. The
multi-channel regularizer TGV [2,3] is defined as:
$$\text{TGV}_{\alpha}^2(u)=\min_w\alpha_1\| |\nabla u–w|_\text{nuc}\|_1+\alpha_0\| |\mathcal{E}w|_\text{frob}\|_1,$$
where
the gradient $$$\nabla u$$$ of the multi-channel image function is a matrix valued function mapping to $$$\mathbb{R}^{n \times
3}$$$. The symmetrized gradient $$$\mathcal{E}w$$$ is a
tensor valued function mapping to $$$\mathbb{R}^{n\times 3\times
3}$$$ and is defined as $$$\mathcal{E}w=\frac{1}{2}(Jw+(Jw)^T)$$$
with $$$Jw$$$ being the Jacobian of $$$w$$$. Coupling of
different channels is achieved with a pointwise nuclear-norm
$$$|\cdot |_\text{nuc}$$$ and pointwise Frobenius norm $$$|\cdot
|_\text{frob}$$$. The nuclear-norm employs a pointwise
penalization of the $$$\ell^1$$$ norm of the singular values of each
matrix, corresponding to the gradient of the multichannel image at one
voxel. The nuclear-norm can be considered as the convex relaxation of the rank, thus, nuclear-norm minimization has a low-rank enforcing effect. As each column of the matrix corresponds to the spatial gradient of one image channel, this enforces
aligned edges amongst different channels. The number of
non-zero singular values is
independent of signal intensity and edge direction and is identical for a unique edge and two aligned edges. The latter makes the regularizer robust against unwanted modification of unique features. This is
illustrated conceptually for the case of a single MR+PET contrast in
Figure
1.
Methods
Numerical
simulations were performed using a brain phantom [4]. Specific lesions
were added to MR and PET. MPRAGE, T2w and FLAIR contrast were
simulated as follows: Matrix size 176×176×30, 8 receive coil
channels, radial acquisition from 32 spokes. K-space data were
corrupted by adding complex Gaussian noise. PET rawdata was simulated
according to the crystal geometry of a whole body MR-PET. The total
number of counts corresponded to a 10min FDG PET head scan.
In-vivo
data of a high-grade-glioma patient was acquired on a clinical 3T
MR-PET system (Siemens Biograph mMR) using a 12-element head coil
array. The study was approved by the IRB, written informed consent
was obtained. The protocol consisted of 6 min simultaneous MRF (voxel
size 1.5×1.5×mm2, 176×176 matrix, 30 slices, slice thickness 3mm)
and PET data acquisition. Data from 32 compressed MR fingerprint sets [5] containing 75 and 30 spokes were reconstructed using the proposed
approach as well as a conventional MRF reconstruction and EM (PET).
Results
Figure
2 shows results of the numerical simulation and RMSE to the ground-truth. Figure 3 visualizes the improved PET resolution by cross-sectional profiles. Simultaneous reconstruction not only preserves
quantitative PET values but shows stronger agreement with the
underlying ground-truth. This is confirmed by quantitative
analysis in Figure 4. Figure 5 shows quantitative MR relaxation
parameter maps and PET images of the high-grade-glioma MRF measurement.
Discussion
The
proposed method has several unique features that makes multi-contrast
and multi-modality image reconstruction feasible: It can deal with
arbitrary sampling operators that describe the different imaging
physics of the individual modalities and integrates different data
terms for modalities with different noise models. The proposed
regularizer makes use of shared features, as demonstrated by the
improved resolution of PET by using the sharp edge information from
the MR contrasts, without compromising individual signal values and contrasts, as
demonstrated by improvements in PET-signal and MRF relaxation
parameter values. In the combination with MR
Fingerprinting, this approach allows a 6-minute comprehensive whole
brain coverage exam that provides both quantitative PET and
MR-relaxation parameters.
Acknowledgements
We acknowledge grant support from NIH P41 EB017183, R01
EB000447 and FWF SFB F3209.References
[1]
Ma et al., Nature, 495: 187-192 (2013),
[2] Knoll et al., Magn Reson Med, 65:480-491 (2011), [3] Martin et al., ISMRM p80 (2015), [4] Aubert-Broche et al., Neuroimage, 32: 138-145 (2006), [5] Cloos et al, ISMRM p330
(2015).