Synopsis
Functional-QSM, promises to offer quantitative
information more directly related to neuronal-activity than BOLD-fMRI and to
partially ameliorate the inherent problem of spatial mismatch between locations
of neuronal-activation and apparent BOLD-detected-activation. The data for fQSM
and fMRI can be simultaneously acquired and mostly processed with the
well-established fMRI toolchains. The current high-field study, evaluates
details of the processing-chain, provides clear evidence that fQSM is capable
(1) to detect neuronal-activation in well-resolved volumes that unambiguously
reside within grey-matter, even after removal of apparent activations
associated with larger-veins, and (2) to identify the visual-network in
resting-state-experiments, thus highlighting a considerable potential of fQSM.Purpose:
Our
aim was 1) to comparatively assess the response to visual and motor activation in
phase- and quantitative susceptibility data (fQSM
1, 2) versus in traditional-BOLD-fMRI data and 2) to use angiography/venography data to selectively
exclude regions of draining-veins for better identification of activated brain
tissue. We also tested whether fQSM data allows identification of the
“visual-(resting-state)-network”.
Materials & Methods:
MRI 2D gradient-echo-EPI
(TR=3s, TE=25ms, FA=85, SENSE=3.5, voxel-dimensions=1.25, 1.25, 1.3mm, recon size=176x176x34 (Volunteer-2: 176x176x38)) images of two consenting volunteers were acquired on a 7T-MR-system(Philips, Achieva).
T1w- Anatomical-Scan: 3D-inversion-recovery gradient-echo, TR=8.2ms,
TE=3.79ms, FA=8, voxel-dimensions=0.94x0.94x1mm,
Phase-Contrast-Angiography: 3D-gradient-echo, TR=35.9ms, TE=7ms,
FA=10, voxel-dimensions=0.898x0.898x0.9mm.
Paradigm3 The quarter-fields of the
visual-cortex were stimulated via 16s of flickering, started with 9s of fixation; 10 blocks of upper-left/lower-right (ULLR) and upper-right/lower-left
(URLL) color-changing wedges were presented
over 200 scans. Subjects’ attention was assured by a simple button-response
task to any contrast alteration of the fixation point.
Phase-Data-Processing Time series data were first registered to the MNI-template.
Phase data were unwrapped via the Laplacian-approach
4,
and background-field-corrected via V-SHARP
5
(Rmax=10vx, threshold=0.1). Quantitative susceptibility maps were generated by
dipolar-inversion of the corrected phase maps using the LSQR algorithm
6. Functional-Phase-Processing
The sign of QSM data was inverted, to match the sign of an activation
change with that in BOLD-fMRI, and the minimum value over all-time series both
for QSM and SHARP data was subtracted from each pixel for compatibility (non-negative
values only) with SPM12
7. SHARP
and QSM images were normalized to MNI-space with a 1.8mm isotropic voxel-size (87x105x76
voxels) and further smoothed with a 2.5mm-Gaussian-kernel. Each data set was
subject to GLM analysis with the Canonical Hemodynamic Response Function (HRF) as
basis function. The phase-data processing was repeated for different SHARP threshold
values (0.04, 0.06, 0.08, 0.1 and 0.12). For the QSM reconstruction, the SHARP data
set with the largest number of activated voxels was used. A temporal-bandpass-filter,
0.01-0.11 Hz, was applied to the fQSM data, and results were compared with those
obtained without the filtering (
Fig.2).
The statistical analyses were repeated for fQSM data after masking
blood-vessels (
Fig.3c). Grey-Matter-Parcellation
was done with the T1w-anatomical images using FreeSurfer
8 (
Fig.4a).
Resting-State-Analysis
Resting-state experiments were performed with identical sequence parameters
as the task-experiment and Independent-Component-Analysis (ICA) was applied to
fQSM and BOLD-fMRI data9.
Results:
Image data of
volunteer-1 at various processing steps and ULLR-activations-maps overlaid on T1w-Anatomy are shown in
Fig.1. Regions
of apparent activations in the motor cortex of fQSM and BOLD-fMRI data sets are
shown in
Fig.2. For
volunteer-2,
SHARP, fQSM and temporally-filtered fQSM activation maps overlaid on
EPI-magnitude data are shown in
Fig.3. SHARP data obtained with a
threshold of 0.1 gave the largest number of activated voxels for both visual-tasks
(
Fig.3, insert top right). There were more ULLR-activated voxels in QSM-
than in SHARP-derived maps (
Fig.3a-b), and in band-pass filtered fQSM
[0.01-0.1 Hz] than in non-filtered fQSM (
Fig.3b, c).
Fig.4 a)
and b) comparatively show fQSM ([0.01 0.1 Hz]) and BOLD-fMRI-derived activation
maps for both visual tasks. The temporal signal evolution during the visual-tasks
showed similar trends for SHARP and fQSM (
Fig.3 – green plots), vs. BOLD
magnitude data (
Fig.4). The relative magnitude variations were
approximately 8% for BOLD-fMRI, 2% for fQSM in veins, and 1.5% for fQSM in GM.
The vessel mask applied to the QSM data prior to spatial smoothing is shown in
Fig.4c).
The blocking of larger veins from the activation analysis did not eliminate all
areas of apparent fQSM activation, in particular, many regions in seemingly
excellent alignment with gray-matter structures survived the masking, as, is
evidenced by comparison with gray-matter structures in the visual cortex
identified by GM-parcellation (
Fig.5a). Results of the resting-state IC-analysis of the fQSM
data and the correspondingly identified visual network are shown and compared to
results the visual-task (
Fig.5b-c).
Discussion:
The spatial mismatch between the
location of actual brain-tissue neuronal activation and corresponding
electric-signal-sources and the location of activation detection by
traditional-BOLD-fMRI is an inherent weakness of fMRI, which, in part, has
physiological causes, such as down-stream displacement of venous-blood with
activation- and neurovascular-coupling induced increased oxygen-saturation
levels in combination with low temporal resolution. However, beyond
physiological causes, the mismatch is exacerbated by distant field and
field-gradient variations provoked by local saturation and susceptibility
changes, which affect distant signal phase- and T2*-weighted signal-magnitude
changes in non-activated-volumes. We believe that the results presented here
support the hypothesis that fQSM may significantly contribute to alleviation of
such latter problems and, besides yielding, from the same data-set, information
complementary to that from BOLD-fMRI, may even have the potential to become
instrumental in new research areas, e.g., cortical-layer specific function
imaging
10.
Acknowledgements
The authors thank to Burak AKIN (Medical Physics, University Hospital Freiburg, Germany) helping with the Freesurfer analysis.References
1. Balla DZ, Sanchez-Panchuelo RM,
Wharton SJ, Hagberg GE, Scheffler K, Francis ST, Bowtell R. Functional
quantitative susceptibility mapping (fQSM). NeuroImage 2014;100:112-124.
2. Özbay PS, Rossi C, Warnock G, Kuhn F,
Akin B, Prüssmann KP, Nanz D. Independent Component Analysis (ICA) of functional
QSM. Proceedings of the Annual Meeting of ISMRM; Toronto, Canada, 2015.
3. Kasper L, Haeberlin M, Dietrich BE,
Gross S, Barmet C, Wilm BJ, Vannesjo SJ, Brunner DO, Ruff CC, Stephan KE,
Pruessmann KP. Matched-filter acquisition for BOLD fMRI. NeuroImage
2014;100:145-160.
4. Schofield MA, Zhu Y. Fast phase
unwrapping algorithm for interferometric applications. Optics letters
2003;28(14):1194-1196.
5. Wu B, Li W, Guidon A, Liu C. Whole
brain susceptibility mapping using compressed sensing. Magnetic resonance in
medicine 2012;67(1):137-147.
6. Li W, Wu B, Liu C.
Quantitative susceptibility mapping of human brain reflects spatial variation
in tissue composition. NeuroImage 2011;55(4):1645-1656.
7. SPM analysis toolbox, UCL, London, UK.
8. Fischl B, Salat DH, Busa E, Albert M,
Dieterich M, Haselgrove C, van der Kouwe A, Killiany R, Kennedy D, Klaveness S,
Montillo A, Makris N, Rosen B, Dale AM. Whole brain segmentation: automated
labeling of neuroanatomical structures in the human brain. Neuron
2002;33(3):341-355.
9. Beckmann CF, Smith SM. Probabilistic
independent component analysis for functional magnetic resonance imaging. IEEE
transactions on medical imaging 2004;23(2):137-152.
10. Koopmans PJ, Barth M, Orzada S, Norris
DG. Multi-echo fMRI of the cortical laminae in humans at 7 T. NeuroImage
2011;56(3):1276-1285.