Modeling demyelination in white matter: the effect of realistic geometries on the susceptibility-weighted MR signal.
Tianyou Xu1, Way Cherng Chen2, Michiel Kleinnijenhuis1, Sean Foxley1, and Karla L Miller1

1University of Oxford, Oxford, United Kingdom, 2Singapore Bioimaging Consortium, Singapore, Singapore

Synopsis

Biophysical modeling of axons has conventionally assumed cylindrical geometries. In reality, axons vary in shape. Models consisting of circles benefit from simplicity, however the consequences of this assumption have not been studied. In this work, simulations incorporating realistic myelin shape derived from electron microscopy are employed to model white matter demyelination. Simulations are compared to a cohort of mice with varying levels of demyelination. Predictions from models that incorporate realistic myelin shape are in better agreement with experimental results in a mouse model of demyelination than those from circular models.

Purpose

To consider the role that axonal shape has on susceptibility-weighted imaging in white matter (WM), with application to demyelination.

Introduction

Recent work has described the magnetic susceptibility of myelin as a significant contributor to gradient echo signal.1-6 Increasingly sophisticated biophysical models are employed to explain these signal properties, including effects like susceptibility anisotropy.5 This work investigates the effect of myelin shape on the modeling of demyelination in WM. First, a structural template of myelin is constructed from electron microscopy (EM) data of mouse WM. Next, simulations of the MR signal magnitude/phase are generated from this realistic template and compared to that of conventional models using circles. Finally, predictions of these two models are evaluated against experimental cuprizone mouse data, an animal model of demyelination.

Signal Simulations

Magnetic field perturbations induced by densely packed axons with arbitrary geometries were modeled using the tensor formulation in the Fourier domain.7 These calculated field maps were used to simulate MR signal evolution in three compartments: extra-axonal, intra-axonal and myelin.4,6 Relevant parameters for the compartments (proton density, T2, magnetic susceptibilities) were based on literature values at 7T, Table 1.5,6,7 Simulations considered both circular axons and more realistic geometries. For the latter, 2D EM data on mouse WM was acquired at 7.16nm resolution and hand-segmented. Packing properties between the EM and circle models are matched: both have a fiber density of 63%, the same Gamma distribution of axon sizes, myelin content and compartmental properties (Figure 1). Note that this rather low fiber density represents only myelinated axons. Demyelination is modeled for both geometries by gradually thinning the myelin structure, producing a range of g-ratios, from 0.71 (normal) to 0.98 (no myelin).

Experimental Methods

Simulations were compared to experimental data acquire in a mouse model of demyelination. Nine mice were fed 0.2% cuprizone diet ad libitum for different durations ranging from 0-42 days to induce varying degrees of demyelination. Images were acquired ex vivo on a 7T animal scanner using a multiple echo gradient echo sequence with TEs=3,7,11...55ms (TR=1.5s, $$$70^\circ$$$flip, 80x80x300$$$\mu m$$$, 3 axial slices, 10 averages). Brains were scanned such that the corpus callosum (CC) was orthogonal to the static field, which is matched in simulation. Background field in phase images were removed using a ‘projection-onto-dipole-fields’ approach.8

Simulation Results

The simulated effect of demyelination on signal magnitude and phase is shown in Figure 3: circle model (top: A-B) and EM-based model (bottom: C-D). Each curve represents a different g-ratio, varying from 0.71 to 0.98. Both models predict amplified signal decay and phase evolution with increased myelination. At a given echo time, the circular model predicts slightly greater signal decay and much greater phase evolution than is predicted by the EM-based model. Given that these simulations were otherwise matched, their differences suggest that myelin geometry has a significant impact on both signal magnitude and phase across a range of demyelination stages.

Experimental Results

Demyelination was confirmed with Luxol fast blue histological stains (not shown). These stains are not sufficiently quantitative to establish whether duration on the diet was monotonically related to myelination, however there were clear differences in stain intensity between mice with long versus short-duration diets. Averaged signal magnitude and phase from an ROI in the CC (Figure 2) are plotted across the nine mice in Figure 4, color-coded by their cuprizone diet duration thereby presumed level of demyelination. There is a clear trend for faster signal decay and greater phase accumulation in mice undergone short diet durations (and therefore more myelin). At TE=55ms, the signal magnitude has attenuated to ~0.15–0.35 and the signal phase varies from ~-0.9-0 radians. These ranges are in good agreement with the predictions from the EM model (Figure 3), while signal predictions from the circular model are larger.

Discussion

Results in this work suggest that myelin geometry has a significant effect on the susceptibility-weighted signal. For the simulation parameters used here (based on literature), EM-driven geometries were more consistent with experimental data than circular geometries. While EM-based geometries are unlikely to represent a sufficiently generalizable framework for signal modeling, these results do have several important implications for interpreting these MR signals. First, literature estimates of these properties have generally been based on fitting a biophysical model to GRE-signals; our results suggest that assumption of circular geometries would bias susceptibility estimates. Conversely, even if the susceptibility values for myelin are known, circular models would led to consistent overestimations of myelin content since they produce larger magnitude and phase changes than realistic geometries. Sensitivity of the GRE-signal to axonal geometry therefore can be expected to bias estimates of microstructural properties from these signals.

Acknowledgements

University of Oxford’s Clarendon Fund Graduate Scholarship, the Sloane Robinson Foundation Scholarship, and the Wellcome Trust.

References

(1) Sukstanskii et al. MRM 2014 (2) Wharton et al. MRM 2014 (3) Lee et al. PNAS 2010 (4) Sati et al. Neuroimage 2013 (5) Wharton et al. PNAS 2012 (6) Chen et al. Neuroimage 2013 (7) Liu C. MRM 2010 (8) Liu T. NMR Biomed 2011

Figures

Figure 1. (left) Packing of nested cylinders (right) EM-derived template of mouse WM. Myelin structure is shown in white; intra axonal space is gray; and extra axonal space is black.

Figure 2. Effect of cuprizone on mouse WM. (left) Magnitude image of healthy mouse with corpus callosum mask (middle) Axial phase image of healthy mouse. (right) Axial phase image of mouse that has undergone a 37 day cuprizone diet. Demyelination of the corpus callosum decreases phase contrast between white and gray matter. Both images acquired at TE=15ms, units in radians.


Figure 3. Signal magnitude and phase predictions from the circular model (top: A-B) and realistic EM-based model (bottom: C-D). Inset in (D) shows the color code of g-ratios for the two models. Phase units are in radians.

Figure 4. Experimental results from cuprizone mouse model for demyelination. (left) Magnitude across nine mice of varying stages of demyelination in white matter corpus callosum. (right) Corresponding signal phase.

Table 1: Physical parameters by compartment based on literature values at 7 Tesla.



Proc. Intl. Soc. Mag. Reson. Med. 24 (2016)
0810