Barbara Wichtmann1,2, Susie Huang1, Qiuyun Fan1, Thomas Witzel1, Elizabeth Gerstner3, Bruce Rosen1, Lothar Schad2, Lawrence Wald1,4, and Aapo Nummenmaa1
1A. A. Martinos Center for Biomedical Imaging, Department of Radiology, Massachusetts General Hospital, Charlestown, MA, United States, 2Computer Assisted Clinical Medicine, Medical Faculty Mannheim, Heidelberg University, Mannheim, Germany, 3Department of Neurology, Massachusetts General Hospital, Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA, United States, 4Harvard-MIT Division of Health Sciences and Technology, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, MA, United States
Synopsis
We
propose a new analysis technique called Linear Multi-scale Modeling (LMM) for
diffusion MRI data that enables detailed microstructural tissue
characterization by separating orientation distributions of restricted and
hindered diffusion water compartments over a range of length scales. We
demonstrate the ability of LMM to estimate volume fractions, compartment sizes
and orientation distributions utilizing both simulations as well as empirical
data from one healthy subject and one tumor patient acquired using a human 3T MRI
scanner equipped with a 300mT/m gradient system. Possible applications of our
modeling framework include characterization of diffusion microstructural
signatures of pathological vs. healthy tissue.Purpose
Diffusion
MRI methods enable noninvasive investigation of tissue microstructure in vivo
1. Restriction Spectrum Imaging (RSI)
2 is a method that reconstructs the diffusion
tissue orientation distribution over a spectrum of length scales. However, by assuming
a spectrum of Gaussian diffusion response functions, the RSI model is unable to
fully capture the complex diffusion time dependency of the signal within
restricted (e.g., intra-cellular) water
compartments. Here we introduce a new analysis framework for diffusion MRI data
called Linear Multi-scale Modeling (LMM) that
extends the RSI approach to represent restricted water compartments with
non-Gaussian response functions. LMM can be employed to estimate tissue
microstructure parameters, including volume fractions of compartments of
variable sizes as well as orientation distribution information of the diffusion
media. Using a human 3T MRI scanner equipped with 300mT/m gradients, we
demonstrate the ability of the LMM approach to distinguish normal gray and
white matter structures in a healthy subject and to characterize the tissue
microenvironment surrounding the resection bed of a brain tumor patient.
Methods
Simulation. Synthetic MRI data with
an SNR of 10 was generated using the Monte Carlo diffusion simulator of Camino3 for diffusion within impermeable, regular packed cylinders with
a range of diameters (2.5-20µm) and intra-axonal volume fractions (0.1-0.9).
Data
acquisition. With approval from the institutional review board, a healthy volunteer
and a patient with a resected left frontal anaplastic oligodendroglioma were
scanned on a dedicated high-gradient 3T MRI scanner (MAGNETOM CONNECTOM,
Siemens Healthcare) with a maximum gradient strength of 300mT/m and maximum
slew rate of 200T/m/s4. Sagittal 2mm isotropic resolution diffusion-weighted spin
echo EPI images were acquired using simultaneous multislice (SMS) imaging4 and zoomed/parallel imaging5 for high-resolution whole-brain coverage. The following
parameters were used: δ/Δ=8/19, 8/30, 6/50 ms, 4-5 diffusion gradient increments
linearly spaced from 55-293mT/m per Δ, TE/TR=77/4400ms, GRAPPA acceleration
factor R=2, and SMS MB factor=2. Diffusion gradients were applied in 64 to 128
non-collinear directions with interspersed b=0 images every 16 directions. The
maximum b-value at the longest diffusion time was 10,350 s/mm2.
Total acquisition time was 90 min.
Data analysis. Following preprocessing to correct for gradient nonlinearity, motion
and eddy currents6, spherical harmonics expansion of order 6/8
with Laplace-Beltrami regularization7 was used to interpolate the diffusion signal on
each q-shell (regularization
parameter λ set to 0.006). The linear multi-scale forward model of different
sized restricted and hindered diffusion compartments was obtained by concatenating
two spectra of response functions (Fig. 1): 1)
a non-Gaussian diffusion response function8 for water restricted inside cylindrical
structures and 2) a Gaussian diffusion response function2 for hindered water and free water diffusion. For
a more compact and efficient linear implementation we parameterized the
orientation distribution of the hindered and restricted compartments with a set
of order 4 and 6 spherical harmonics, respectively. To obtain the orientation
distribution functions and corresponding volume fractions, the multi-scale
deconvolution inverse problem was solved by standard least-squares estimation
with Tikhonov regularization.
Results
Analysis
of our simulation data yielded a fiber orientation distribution spectrum
consistent with the simulated axon diameters and volume fractions (Fig. 2). For empirical data, the brain maps
comprising the signal from all restricted, hindered, and free compartments
showed a high fraction of restricted water within the densely packed white
matter and free water nearly exclusively originating from the ventricles (Fig. 3). Voxel-wise estimated volume fractions
of the different sized water compartments were clearly distinguishable between
different anatomical structures within the brain (Fig.
4). In the brain tumor patient, the area surrounding the tumor resection
showed distinct areas of restricted and hindered water with a different
signature compared to normal gray and white matter (Fig.
4). For each length scale, the fiber orientation distribution was
obtained, allowing for scale-specific tractography (Fig.
5).
Discussion
When
combined with cutting-edge acquisition techniques, the LMM framework offers a
powerful analysis method to separate orientation distributions of restricted
and hindered diffusion water compartments over a range of length scales,
thereby allowing more detailed characterization of tissue microstructure. The
estimation of restricted and hindered volume fractions and compartment sizes
may provide insight into the distinct microstructural features of healthy and
diseased tissue, while orientation distribution information at different length
scales could give additional information about structural connectivity in the
brain and provide a roadmap for surgical planning. Future work will focus on optimization
of the acquisition protocol and refinement of the reconstruction methods.
Conclusion
LMM
provides detailed characterization of tissue microstructure and orientation
distribution that may enable the development of distinct diffusion microstructural
signatures of pathology compared to healthy tissue.
Acknowledgements
Research reported in this publication was supported by the National Institutes of Health under NIBIB award number R00EB015445, P41EB015896, U01MH093765 (Human Connectome Project), 1U01CA154601, K23CA169021-01.References
[1] Yablonskiy DA et al. NMR Biomed 23: 661-81 (2010). [2] White NS et al. Hum. Brain Mapp. 34: 327-346 (2013). [3] Cook PA et al. ISMRM 14: 2759 (2006). [4] Setsompop K et al. NI 80: 220-233 (2013). [5] Eichner C et al. MRM 71: 1518-1525 (2014). [6] Fan Q. et al. Brain Connect 4: 718-726 (2014). [7] Descoteaux M et al. MRM 58: 497-510 (2007). [8] van Gelderen P et al. Journal of magnetic resonance 103: 255-260 (1994)