Synopsis
Slow fluctuating (< 0.1 Hz) BOLD signals
during baseline conditions or ‘resting-state’ have seen interest in numerous
studies, both in healthy and disease. Here we investigate cerebral vascular reactivity
and baseline cerebral blood volume contributions to the slow fluctuating baseline
BOLD signal.Purpose
Investigate relations between hypercapnic
and hyperoxic BOLD responses and slow baseline BOLD signal fluctuations.
Background
Slow fluctuating (< 0.1 Hz) BOLD signals
during baseline conditions or ‘resting-state’ have seen interest in numerous
studies, both in healthy and disease. Whereas temporal coherence of these
fluctuations between regions have been linked to neuronal functional networks
1,
the amplitude of these fluctuations have been used in normalization procedures
of BOLD responses
2,3 (aiming at reducing inter-subject variability) as
proxy for vascularization (CO2 vessel reactivity), but also a proxy
for neuronal activity in studies on age effects and disease
4,5,6,7.
The aim of this study was to shed light on the origins of these slow fluctuating
BOLD signals in terms of CO2 vessel reactivity and baseline cerebral blood
volume contributions.
Methods
Healthy volunteers (n=45; age range=25 – 76
yrs) were scanned at 3T (Philips) with no previous history of cerebrovascular
disease, other brain disease or visible structural lesions on MR imaging. These
subjects were also included in a previous study
8. BOLD
measurements were obtained using dual-echo pCASL MRI using the following
acquisition parameters: multi-slice single-shot EPI, SENSE=2,
TR/TE
1/TE
2=4000/13.8/36.3ms, voxel size=3x3x7mm
3, slice gap=1mm,
FOV=240x240x87mm
3, label duration=1650ms, postlabel delay=1550ms,
volumes=135, scan time=18min40s. The breathing paradigm consisted of two
normoxic hypercapnic periods in which end-tidal CO
2 (EtCO
2) was targeted to
progressively increase by approximately 10mmHg above resting baseline EtCO
2
over a period of 75 seconds. The hypercapnic periods were interleaved with a
single normocapnic hyperoxic period during which EtO2 was targeted
at 300mmHg (See Figure 1). Gasses were administered using a computer-controlled
rebreathing approach (RespirAct
TM, Thornhill Research Inc.). BOLD
time series (computed by optimally combining the two echoes) were motion
corrected (FLIRT), linearly detrended (AFNI), and spatially smoothed with a 5mm
FWHM Gaussian kernel. Amplitude maps of slow fluctuating BOLD signals were computed
by estimating the mean square-root of the power in the 0.01 – 0.08 Hz frequency
band for each voxel during the baseline period (first 200s). Amplitude maps of
slow fluctuating BOLD were subsequently normalized by the mean signal averaged
over the baseline period and all voxels in the brain mask. Maps of hypercapnic
and hyperoxic BOLD signal changes (%) were computed using the EtCO
2 and EtO
2
traces as regressors in a general linear model (Feat, FSL). Hypercapnic %BOLD data were normalized by each subject’s pEtCO
2 (yielding %BOLD/mmHg). The hyperoxic BOLD signal changes
were used for obtaining baseline venous cerebral blood volume (vCBV) information. Finally,
all maps were registered to common MNI space for comparison purposes in cortical gray matter areas.
Results
Maps of BOLD (%) hypercapnic cerebral reactivity
(HC-CVR), hyperoxic BOLD reactivity (≈baseline cerebral venous blood volume,
HO-CVR) and amplitude of baseline slow fluctuating BOLD signals (SFBS) are
shown in Figure 1 (averaged over all subjects). Corresponding density scatter plots maps
(cortical gray matter mask in MNI space) shows a high correlation between all three
measures;
R2 = 0.70 (HC-CVR vs. SFBS) , R
2 = 0.51 (HO-CVR
vs. SFBS), R
2 = 0.56 (HC-CVR vs. HO-CVR).
Discussion & Conclusion
A substantial amount of the information
imbedded in the slow fluctuating BOLD signal (SFBS) during baseline conditions is heavily weighted
by the baseline cerebral venous blood volume (vCBV). Taking the hyperoxic %BOLD
signal changes as a proxy for baseline vCBV we observed that 51% of the spatial
variation in SFBF can explained by baseline vCBV– we hypothesize this is largely
due to the distribution of large vessels. When normalizing the SFBS by total amplitude
across all frequencies (fractional amplitude of low-frequency fluctuation
(ALFF), supposedly to reduce large vessel contributions
9) still 39%
of variation is explained by vCBV (maps not shown here). Further, 70% of the
spatial variation in SFBF is explained by BOLD HC-CVR variation (of which 56%
is subsequently explained by baseline vCBV). This study indicates that baseline
vCBV is dominant modulator of the BOLD signal. Care should be taken when
attributing BOLD signal changes/fluctuations to solely neuronal activity or as
a proxy for CO2 vessel reactivity, especially in disease cases where
cerebral blood volume can be compromised.
References
1Van den Heuvel M.P., Hulshoff Pol H.E.,
Exploring the brain network: a review on resting-state fMRI functional
connectivity. European Neuropsychopharmacol (2010); 20:519-534.
2Kazan S.M., Mohammadi S., Callaghan M.F., et al. Vascular autorescaling of fMRI (VasA fMRI) improves sensitivity of population studies: A pilot study. Neuroimage (2015)
3Di X., Kunnarpatti S.S., Rypma B., et al. Calibrating BOLD fMRI Activations with Neurovascular and Anatomical Constraints. Cerebral Cortex (2013); 23:255-263
4Kunnarpatti
S.S., Rypma B., Biswal B.B., Prediction of task-related BOLD fMRI with
amplitude signatures of resting-state fMRI. Frontiers in Systems Neuroscience (2012);
6(7) 1- 10
5Zuo X. Di
Martino A., Kelly C., et al. The oscillating brain: Complex and reliable.
Neuroimage (2010); 49:1432-1445
6Hu S., Herta H., Chao A.
et al. Changes in
cerebral morphometry and amplitude of low frequency fluctuations of BOLD
signals during healthy aging: correlation with inhibitory control. Brain Structure and Fucntion (2014); 219:983-994.
7Turner A., Damaraju E., van Erp T.G.M., et al. A multi-site resting state fMRI study
on the amplitude of low frequency fluctuations in schizophrenia. Frontiers in
Neuroscience (2013); 7(113) 1-13
8De Vis JB, Hendrikse J, Bhogal A, et al. Age-related
changes in brain hemodynamics; A calibrated MRI study. Human Brain Mapping (2015).
9Zou Q., Zhu C., Yang Y. et al. An
improved detection of amplitude of low-frequency fluctuation (ALFF) for resting-state
fmri: fractional ALFF. Journal of Neuroscience Methods (2008); 172: 137-141