Synopsis
This work presents a model-based fat/water separation
technique for radial sampling, which takes into account the off-resonant
blurring of fat and integrates both compressed sensing and parallel imaging. By
combining this reconstruction scheme with 3D radial stack-of-stars sampling, volumetric
and motion-robust water and fat maps as well as in-phase/opposed-phase images can
be generated under free-breathing. The approach is demonstrated at 1.5T and 3T,
including volunteer and patient measurements.Purpose
Radial
3D GRE imaging is increasingly used for various clinical routine applications
due to its inherently higher robustness to motion1. One major
limitation consists in the strong blurring of off-resonant signal components
such as fat, which makes it necessary to always use spectral fat suppression.
However, spectral fat-suppression techniques typically fail in regions with
large field inhomogeneities. Furthermore, use of fat suppression makes it
impossible to assess the local fat content, as needed, e.g., for identifying
fat-containing lesions such as angiomyolipomas. Therefore, clinical protocols currently still require acquisition of conventional Cartesian
non-fat-suppressed T1-weighted images in in-phase/opposed-phase conditions.
To
overcome these limitations, we describe a model-based fat/water separation
technique for radial sampling, which takes into account the off-resonant
blurring of fat and integrates both compressed sensing and parallel imaging to achieve rapid acquisition.
Methods
Signal
model:
The
aim of the reconstruction approach is to estimate separate fat and water maps
directly from the k-space data. The general optimization problem for this
purpose can be written as2:
$$\text{argmin}\sum_{c,t}\|E(W,F,\Phi)_{c,t}-y_{c,t}\|_2^2+\lambda_W\text{TV}(W)+\lambda_F\text{TV}(F)+\lambda_\Phi\|\Theta\Phi\|_2^2$$
where
$$$y$$$ is the acquired radial k-space data, and $$$E$$$ is the forward
operator that synthesizes k-space data from the to-be-estimated water
($$$W$$$), fat ($$$F$$$), and B0 field maps ($$$\Phi$$$). Compressed
Sensing is included via total variation penalty terms for both the fat and
water maps. In addition, a smoothness constraint $$$\Theta$$$ is applied to the
field map. The forward operator $$$E$$$ is composed of the operations:
$$E(W,F,\Phi)_{c,t}=\text{FT}\left(C_c\cdot\exp\left(2\pi
i\cdot\Phi\cdot t_n\right)\cdot
W\right)+D(t)\cdot\text{FT}\left(C_c\cdot\exp\left(2\pi i\cdot\Phi\cdot
t_n\right)\cdot F\right)$$
where
$$$FT$$$ is the gridding operator and $$$t_n$$$ are the different echo times.
To account for the off-resonant blurring of fat due to the applied radial
acquisition scheme, $$$D(t)$$$ models the chemical shift in k-space3,
taking into account the exact readout time points $$$t=t_n+\tau_{n,k}$$$ of the
samples $$$k$$$ of each spoke:
$$D(t)=\sum_{m=1}^6\alpha_m\cdot\exp\left(2\pi
i\cdot\Delta f_m\cdot(t_n+\tau_{n,k})\right)$$
In
addition, a 6-peak multi-frequency model was applied. To incorporate parallel
imaging, multiplications with the different coil sensitivity profiles $$$C_c$$$
were integrated into the forward operator.
Data
acquisition and reconstruction:
IRB-approved
abdominal scans of a healthy volunteer were performed during free-breathing on
a 1.5T whole-body scanner (Magnetom Aera, Siemens Healthcare GmbH) using an 18-channel
body-array and a 24-channel spine-array. A 3D stack-of-stars trajectory was
employed for data acquisition, which performs Cartesian sampling along the
slice direction and radial sampling in-plane according to the golden-angle
scheme. Within each TR, three echoes were acquired using a bipolar readout. 64
partitions with each 256 radial projections were collected in 3:10min using the following parameters: FOV = 300x300x160mm3, matrix size =
256x256x64, resolution = 1.17x1.17x2.50mm3, TR = 11.6ms, TE =
2.34/5.59/8.84ms, BW = 330Hz/px, flip angle = 12deg.
Furthermore,
both a volunteer and a patient were measured with IRB-approval on a 3T scanner (Magnetom Skyra).
For these acquisitions, a readout bandwidth of 270Hz/px was used, while other
acquisition parameters were similar to the 1.5T measurement. The patient
measurement was conducted after contrast injection.
Reconstructions
were performed offline in Matlab (Mathworks, MA) using a Gauss-Newton algorithm,
in analogy to prior work on compressed-sensing-based fat/water separation for
Cartesian data2. Due to the non-convex cost function of the
optimization problem, it is crucial to use a good initial guess for the field
map. This was achieved by analytically calculating possible field map values
with subsequent region growing2. Coil sensitivity maps were
estimated using the adaptive combination technique3.
Results
Figure
1 shows the estimated water and fat maps, as well as synthetically generated
in-phase/opposed-phase images from an exemplary transversal slice. Clear
separation of fat and water could be achieved with only slight streaking artifacts
due to breathing motion.
Figure
2 shows results of the patient measurement, revealing liver cysts (arrows) in
the water image.
The
effect of removing the fat blurring in the volunteer measurement at 3T is shown
in Figure 3.
Discussion and Conclusion
This
work demonstrates how the combination of 3D radial stack-of-stars sampling and
model-based reconstruction with fat/water separation enables motion-robust
volumetric radial MRI without need for spectral fat suppression.
Parallel imaging and compressed sensing can be incorporated by including
coil-sensitivity profiles and L1-based penalty terms into the
optimization problem. The fat blurring is removed by including its frequency
deviation into the signal model. For routine clinical use of the proposed
method, a robust technique for initial field map estimation is necessary, which
is ongoing work.
After
estimation of the water and fat maps, in-phase/opposed-phase images can be
generated synthetically. Therefore, the approach can be used to replace both,
fat-suppressed (radial) acquisition and non-fat-suppressed (Cartesian) in-phase/opposed-phase
acquisitions with only a single radial free-breathing scan. This promises to
shorten abdominal MR examinations considerably and improve patient comfort.
Acknowledgements
NIH 5R01EB018308
We especially thank Mariya Doneva
for providing her Compressed Sensing fat-water reconstruction code within the
fat-water toolbox (http://ismrm.org/workshops/FatWater12/data.htm),
which served as a basis for our developments.
References
1. Block KT et al., Towards Routine Clinical Use
of Radial Stack-of-Stars 3D Gradient-Echo Sequences for Reducing Motion
Sensitivity, JKSMRM 18:87-106 (2014)
2. Doneva M et al., Compressed Sensing for
Chemical Shift-Based Water-Fat Separation, Magn Reson Med 64:1749-1759 (2010)
3. Brodsky EK et al., Generalized k-Space
Decomposition with Chemical Shift Correction for Non-Cartesian Water-Fat
Imaging, Magn Reson Med 59:1151-1164 (2008)
4. Walsh DO et al., Adaptive Reconstruction of
Phased Array MR Imagery, Magn Reson Med 43:682-690 (2000)