Laura Claire Saunders1, Neil J Stewart1, Charlotte Hammerton1, David Capener1, Valentina O Puntmann2, David G Kiely3, Martin J Graves4, Andy Swift1, and Jim M Wild1
1Academic Unit of Radiology, The University of Sheffield, Sheffield, United Kingdom, 2Department of Cardiovascular Imaging, Kings College London, London, United Kingdom, 3The University of Sheffield, Sheffield, United Kingdom, 4University of Cambridge School of Clinical Medicine, University of Cambridge, Cambridge, United Kingdom
Synopsis
Patients with suspected
pulmonary hypertension (n=94) and healthy volunteers (n=26) underwent T1
mapping of the right ventricle with a Modified Look Locker inversion recovery (MOLLI)
sequence at 1.5T. MOLLI images were registered using pairwise registration to
synthetic images produced using a simplified inversion recovery model to
correct cardiac or respiratory motion. 89% of patients and 100% of healthy
volunteers were successfully registered, with mean T1s of 1.00±0.10s and 0.97±0.06s (septal), 1.05±0.11s and
0.97±0.06s (right ventricular insertion point) and 1.02±0.11s and 1.04±0.13s (right ventricular free wall)
respectively.Background
Pulmonary hypertension (PH) is a condition characterised by
increased blood pressure in the pulmonary artery, with a diagnostic criteria of
mean pulmonary artery pressure ≥25mmHg
as measured by right heart catheter. Patients with pulmonary
hypertension may experience shortness of breath, leading to difficulty maintain
breath hold during a CMR (cardiac magnetic resonance) scan.
Right ventricular remodelling and failure occur as a result
of prolonged afterload. Accurate measurement of the changes in RV free wall
tissue would be of clinical value. T1
elevation has been measured in animal models with pulmonary hypertension in the
right ventricular insertion point and linked to severity of disease [1]
In comparison to the in the septum and insertion points the right ventricular
free wall is less spatially resolved on an MRI and it is unknown whether
accurate measurement of the T1 can be made. It is therefore of interest to
perform accurate T1 mapping in the right ventricular free wall and insertion
points, in patients with pulmonary hypertension in comparison with age and sex
matched volunteers.
Purpose
The aim of this study was to measure accurate myocardial T1,
in the right ventricular free wall, septum and insertion points in patients
with pulmonary hypertension and age and sex matched volunteers using a custom
image registration method to correct for respiratory and
cardiac motion.
Methods
All patients and volunteers underwent MOLLI imaging on a 1.5
T GE scanner, using a 3-3-5 image acquisition pattern and a flip angle of 35o.
94 consecutive patients referred from a PH referral centre with suspected PH
were analysed. 26 age and sex matched volunteers were recruited for this study.
All acquired MOLLI images were registered using pair-wise
image registration to synthetic images, based upon the work of Xue et al [2]. However,
in this work synthetic images were created using a non-iterative simplified
inversion recovery model (see Eq. 1) with an input of three pre-registered
acquired images: the first image, the fourth image and the last image. The
fourth image is included based on empirical optimisation to provide a good
model fitting at the myocardial null point. The model assumes: the last image
(image l)
is fully recovered; that all signal is fully inverted, and that T1 is equivalent to
T1*. This method is less time and computation intensive than an iterative
energy minimisation solution, whilst still producing spatially aligned synthetic images with
similar contrast to acquired images, enabling registration. See figure 1.
Image registration was performed using a non-rigid, intensity based, registration
toolkit ShIRT [3] which was integrated into the custom T1
mapping algorithm in Matlab.
$$ s(t)=s(l)-2s(l)-e^{\frac{-t}{T1}} Eq 1 $$
Acquired MOLLI images were overlaid pre and post
registration to demonstrate areas of motion correction. T1 maps were produced
pre and post registration to highlight areas of T1 correction due to motion
correction. See Figure 2.
T1 analysis regions of interest (see Figure 2) covered the
entire septum, and as much RVFW as was visible. See Figure 3.
Results
84/94 of all acquired MOLLI images from patients with
suspected PH were free from motion post registration, of which 83/94 were also
free from artefact and therefore able to produce accurate T1 maps, and were
used in the results section. See Figure 4.
Right ventricular free wall was identifiable in 73/83
patients, and 22/26 healthy volunteers.
T1s in the myocardium of patients were found to be: septal 1.00±0.10s; right ventricular insertion point 1.05±0.11s;
right ventricular free wall 1.02±0.11s).
Healthy volunteer myocardial T1’s were consistent with known
values: septal T1 = 0.97±0.06s;
right ventricular insertion point T1 =0.97±0.06s
[4],
right ventricular free wall was found to be 1.04±0.13s.
Discussion and conclusion
Image registration to synthetic
images, using a simplified inversion recovery model, created accurate (motion free) T1
maps were in 90% of all patients with pulmonary hypertension and 100%
of healthy volunteers.
Right ventricular free wall was partially
to fully spatially resolved in 88% of patients and 85% of healthy volunteers. Right
ventricular free wall T1 was measured to be 1.02±0.11s and 1.04±0.13s
in patients and volunteers respectively. The elevated T1 in volunteer right ventricular free
wall, compared to septal T1, indicates partial volume effects within the right
ventricular free wall measurements, and therefore inaccurate RVFW T1 values.
The use of image registration can produce accurate T1 maps in both
healthy volunteers, and patients with pulmonary hypertension who have
difficulty maintaining breath hold. T1 values measured healthy volunteers
within the septum and right ventricular insertion point are consistent with
known values.
Acknowledgements
This work was funded by the National Institute of Health Research (NIHR).References
1. Garcia-Alvarez, A., et al., Association of Myocardial T1-Mapping CMR
With Hemodynamics and RV Performance in Pulmonary Hypertension.
Jacc-Cardiovascular Imaging, 2015. 8(1):
p. 76-82.
2. Xue, H., et al., Motion correction for myocardial T1 mapping
using image registration with synthetic image estimation. Magn Reson Med,
2012. 67(6): p. 1644-55.
3. Barber, D.C. and
D.R. Hose, Automatic segmentation of
medical images using image registration: diagnostic and simulation
applications. J Med Eng Technol, 2005. 29(2):
p. 53-63.
4. Rogers, T., et
al., Standardization of T1 measurements
with MOLLI in differentiation between health and disease--the ConSept study.
Journal of cardiovascular magnetic resonance : official journal of the Society
for Cardiovascular Magnetic Resonance, 2013. 15: p. 78.