Gorane Santamaria1, Jessica Buck2,3, Leah Best4, David Clark5, Judith Silcock5, Peter Lau4, Saadallah Ramadan6, Scott Quadrelli3,7, Peter Malycha3, and Carolyn Mountford3
1Hospital Clinic de Barcelona, Barcelona, Spain, 2Oxford University, Oxford, United Kingdom, 3Translational Research Institute, Brisbane, Australia, 4Hunter New England Area Health, Newcastle, Australia, 5The Breast and Endocrine Centre, Gateshead, Gateshead, Australia, 6University of Newcastle, Australia, Newcastle, Australia, 7Queensland University of Technology, Brisbane, Australia
Synopsis
Women
carrying the BRCA1 and BRCA2 gene mutations exhibited lipid and metabolite
profiles consistent with very early deregulation recorded earlier in cancer
cell models. The deregulation was different for BRCA1 and BRCA2. Here we report
a longitudinal study where these same women are monitored every six month using
the L-COSY MRS method and every 12 month with contrast enhanced MRI. For most women in the study the biomarkers
remained relatively stable over time. Of the 6 BRCA1 and 10 BRCA2 patients examined,
one BRCA1 patient and one BRCA2 patient showed further deregulation.Introduction
Women with mutations in the BRCA1 or BRCA2 genes have an
increased risk of developing breast cancer. While lifetime risk is up to 60%
for BRCA1 and 45% for BRCA2, some women develop breast cancer at an early age
while other women with the same mutation never develop breast cancer. There is
currently no method to predict which women will develop breast cancer nor when
they will develop it. As a result, many women undergo a prophylactic mastectomy
to mitigate risk. Two dimensional localised Correlated Spectroscopy (2D L-COSY)
with a basis from earlier chemical analyses of cell models has provided
evidence suggesting a premalignant condition for which distinct chemical
profiles can be recorded (1). This information can now be recorded in vivo as
part of an MRI scan using a 3T scanner. The aim was to evaluate an early
longitudinal study of women carrying the BRCA gene mutations using the 2D
L-COSY method to monitor chemical changes in breast tissue that could indicate a
progression towards breast cancer that may be identified by escalating lipid deregulation.
Methods
Six women with BRCA1
gene mutations and 10 women with BRCA2 gene mutations were enrolled in the
ongoing study by the Breast and Endocrine Centre in Gateshead, Newcastle,
Australia. Patients were assessed by a breast surgeon according to protocol
which included mammography, and ultrasound as necessary, to ensure no overt
malignancy was present. In vivo 2D L-COSY was recorded at 3T on a Siemens Skyra
or Prisma using a 16 channel breast coil. Participants first underwent standard
diagnostic contrast enhanced breast MRI, which was reviewed by two independent
radiologists using BIRADS scoring. The 15x15x15mm3 spectroscopic voxel was then
placed in the lower outer quadrant midway between fibroglandular and fat
tissues in the breast. The L-COSY sequence was applied with TE initial 30ms, TR
1.5s, 8 averages per increment, bandwidth 2000 Hz, t1 increment 0.8ms, vector
size 1024 points, RF offset frequency 3.2ppm, and 64 increments. The “WET”
method of water suppression was applied. Processing was undertaken using
previously reported parameters (2). Cross and diagonal peak volumes were
measured using Felix software, with the (CH2)n diagonal peak at 1.30 ppm used as
the internal chemical shift reference. Due to the absence of a reliable
internal concentration standard, peak ratios were calculated with respect to
the following reference peaks (F2, F1): (2.75,2.75)ppm; (1.30,1.30)ppm; and
(4.25,4.25)ppm. L-COSY was undertaken on patients every 6 months and a full MRI
exam every 12 months to examine longitudinal trends. The peak volume ratios of
the L-COSY spectrum, identified previously as biomarkers of women carrying the
BRCA gene mutations (2), were used to examine longitudinal trends, with the
patient’s first scan used as a baseline. To ensure magnet stability a phantom
was examined regularly.
Results
Examination of longitudinal trends over 30 months in some
cases in the biomarker ratios showed that most women exhibited relatively
consistent lipid and metabolite ratios over time. Two cases of interest were
identified which showed altering biomarker ratios when compared to their
baseline scan (Figure 1). The case of interest in the BRCA1 group showed a 35%
increase in the lipid crosspeak E signal at (2.02, 1.30) ppm, a 75% decrease in
the composite choline resonance at (3.23, 3.23) ppm, and a 74% decreased in the
composite choline, glycine and myo-inositol resonance (3.70, 3.70) ppm. The
case of interest in the BRCA2 group, where a cancer had been removed from the
other breast, showed a 44% increase in the lipid crosspeak E signal, a 62%
decrease in the lipid methyl group signal at (0.90,0.90)ppm, and a 70% decrease
in the cholesterol methyl group resonance at (0.70,0.70)ppm.
Radiological reporting:
All cases were BIRADS 1 or BIRADS 2 and showed no MRI changes during the course
of the study, including the two cases in which biochemical changes were
recorded by 2D L-COSY.
Discussion/Conclusions
This is a follow up study to that
where we demonstrated that women carrying the BRCA1 and BRCA2 gene mutations
exhibited lipid and metabolite profiles (2) consistent with very early
deregulation in cancer cell models (1). Moreover the deregulation was different
for BRCA1 and BRCA2. Here we are undertaking a longitudinal study where these
same women are monitored every six months. For most women in the study these
biomarkers remained relatively stable over time. Of the 6 BRCA1 and 10 BRCA2
patients examined, only one BRCA1 patient and one BRCA2 patient showed further
deregulation.
Acknowledgements
No acknowledgement found.References
1) Lean et al 1993, Assessment of human colorectal biopsies by 1H MRS: Correlation with histopathology, Magnetic Resonance in Medicine, 30 (5), 525-533
2) Ramadan et al 2015, Lipid and metabolite deregulation in the breast tissue of women carrying BRCA1 and BRCA2 genetic mutations, Radiology, 275 (3), 675-682