Lisa Maria Harris1,2, Ella Hodder2,3, Mara Cercignani2, Jan Bush2, Derek Convill3, Paul Colley1, and Nicholas Dowell2
1Radiological Sciences, Brighton and Sussex University Hospitals NHS Trust, Brighton, United Kingdom, 2Clinical Imaging Sciences Centre, Brighton and Sussex Medical School, Brighton, United Kingdom, 3Computing, Engineering and Mathematics, University of Brighton, Brighton, United Kingdom
Synopsis
An assessment was made to determine whether proteoglycan
concentration could accurately be quantified at 1.5T using 1HMRS in a group of
13 healthy volunteers. A peak from the
N-acetyl resonance associated with proteoglycan was seen in all thirteen
spectra, and reliably measured (308.8±59.9).
This compares favourably with studies performed at higher field
strengths, thus showing that is it possible even at 1.5T to measure
proteoglycans in intervertebral discs.Introduction
Intervertebral discs (IVDs) are fibrocartilaginous
cushions that act to protect both the vertebrae and the brain by working as a
shock-absorbing system for the spine.
IVDs are composed of two components, the annulus fibrosus (a strong
outer layer) that encloses the nucleus pulposus (containing a hydrated gel–like
material that is resistant to compression).
Proteoglycan molecules (PGs) are an important component
of IVDs, found in both the annulus fibrosis and nucleus pulposus. PGs serve to
both attract and retain water, contributing to the hydration of the tissue, and
also serve the purpose of regulation of matrix assembly. The loss of PG from the disc is the main
chemical change observed in intervertebral disc degeneration [1]. Therefore, it is of clinical interest to be
able to reliably measure PG on a clinical MR scanner.
The purpose of this study was to assess the feasibility
of reliably quantifying PG concentration using 1H magnetic resonance
spectroscopy (1HMRS) at 1.5T, and to determine how this relates to both the
disc height, disc volume and the T2* values for the disc.
Methods
Scans were performed on a group of 13 healthy volunteers (age
= 27.5 ± 3.3 yo; 8F, 5M) using a 1.5T Siemens Avanto with the inbuilt spine
coil. All participants gave written
informed consent and the study was approved by the local research ethics
committee.
1HMRS was performed using the following parameters: TE =
30ms, TR = 1500ms, and 256 averages. Voxels were 25mmx20mm in the axial plane
and 8mm in thickness, contained fully within the disc with minimum infiltration
of signal from neighbouring vertebrae (figure 1). Saturation bands were placed surrounding the voxel
to reduce signal from external tissues. Voxels were all placed within lumbar
discs, either between L3 and L4 or L4 and L5, whichever was the thickest. Water unsuppressed data was also collected (16
averages) to allow for eddy current correction and quantification. Shimming was
performed manually, to obtain the best possible line-width. The total
acquisition time was approximately 7 minutes.
Peaks arising from the N-acetyl resonance (2.04ppm)
associated with PG were fitted, using the jMRUI processing tool with AMARES [2]. Attempts were also made to fit peaks associated
with lipids and macromolecules (1–1.5ppm, LMM13) and carbohydrates
(3.54ppm). LMM13 peaks are likely to be
due to signal infiltration from outside the voxel, but could interfere with
measurement of PG if very large.
Additional multi-echo gradient-echo scans were also performed
to measure T2* of the selected disc, to determine whether any correlation can
be seen with PG. All the discs were
measured for both thickness and overall volume; this was also assessed for
correlation.
All results are quoted as mean±sd.
Results and Discussion
Thirteen participants were scanned as part of this study,
all had corresponding volumetric measures and nine had T2* values. The quality was acceptable in all spectra,
with an average line width of 8.0±2.0Hz and SNR of 11.2±6.8. All of the spectra showed a clear singlet at
2.04ppm relating to PG (figure 2). Three of the data sets did show LMM13
contamination, however PG was still measureable in these spectra. Although, most of the spectra exhibited a
peak for the carbohydrates, this is not reliably measured due to residual
saturation from the water suppression.
Zuo et al [3] showed that PG could be reliably measured
using 1HMRS at 3T, using Pfirrmann grading as a variable. Controls with no discography (Pfirrmann grade
1) showed values for water/PG of 299±62.
In the study presented here, we obtained a value of 308.8±59.9. This agreement indicates that it is feasible
to reliably measure PG concentrations at 1.5T. The majority of clinical MR
scanners are 1.5T, and not 3T. Therefore,
in order for it to be of use clinically, it is necessary to prove 1HMRS of IVDs
is robust at 1.5T. A robust method of PG
quantification at 1.5T has been achieved here.
Mean values for the other measure were as follows: Disc
thickness = 10.0±1.0mm, Disc volume = 12.4±2.6cm³, T2* = 50.9±7.9. Correlations
were sought between PG concentration and: age, disc thickness, disc volume and
disc T2*. There was no correlation
between disc volume or disc thickness and PG concentration, although a trend
was emerging between PG concentration and T2* (R² = 0.57). This was limited by number of data sets
available, and the sample size would need to be significantly increased in
order to accurately determine whether there is any correlation present.
Conclusion
It has been shown that PG can be reliably quantified
in IVDs of healthy controls at 1.5T.
Acknowledgements
We gratefully acknowledge the support of the radiographers at the Clinical
Imaging Sciences CentreReferences
[1] Curtis et al, J Bone Joint Surg Br 87: Supp III 230 (2005)
[2] Vanhamme et al, J Magn Reson 129:35 (1997)
[3] Zuo et al, Spine 37:6 (2012)