Changho Choi1, Thomas Huber2, Anna Tietze3, Byung Se Choi4, Jung Hee Lee5, Seung-Koo Lee6, Alexander Lin7, and Sunitha Thakur8
1UT Southwestern Medical Center, Dallas, TX, United States, 2Technical University of Munich, Munich, Germany, 3Aarhus University Hospital, Aarhus, Denmark, 4Seoul National University College of Medicine, Seongnam, Korea, Republic of, 5Sungkyunkwan University School of Medicine, Seoul, Korea, Republic of, 6Yonsei University College of Medicine, Seoul, Korea, Republic of, 7Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA, United States, 8Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center, New York, NY, United States
Synopsis
The non-invasive identification of elevated 2-hydroxyglutarate
(2HG) in IDH-mutated gliomas by 1H MRS in vivo is a major breakthrough in brain
tumor research. Studies have shown that optimized long-TE approaches may confer
advantages over short-TE MRS for detecting 2HG. Here we report an evaluation of
the feasibility of long-TE 2HG MRS in Philips, Siemens and GE 3T scanners. Echo
times were optimized, with numerical simulations and phantom validation, for the
vendor-specific RF pulses. In-vivo data from IDH-mutated glioma patients,
obtained in the three vendors, are discussed.PURPOSE
Following the discovery of
2-hydroxyglutarate (2HG) production in gliomas with mutations in isocitrate
dehydrogenase 1 and 2
1, the capability of in-vivo detection of this
onco-metabolite by MRS has become a central interest in cancer research. Recent studies
2,3 showed that
optimized long-TE MRS may be advantageous over standard short-TE MRS for 2HG
measurement at 3T. Here we aim to evaluate the performance of long-TE MRS for 2HG
detection in Philips, Siemens and GE 3T scanners.
METHODS
Among
the five non-exchangeable J-coupled proton resonances of 2HG, the C4-proton
resonances at ~2.25 ppm give rise to the largest signal in most experimental
situations. The dependence of this 2.25-ppm resonance on the subecho times of PRESS,
TE1 and TE2, was examined with numerical density-matrix
simulations that incorporated the slice-selective RF and gradient pulses which
are readily available in Philips, Siemens, and GE clinical scanners (Fig. 1). In-vitro experiments were conducted on a
phantom solution
with 2HG and Gly at three sites. In-vivo
experiments were performed in patients with IDH-mutated gliomas at multiple centers (9 sites). Spectra
were analyzed with LCModel using calculated spectra of 20 metabolites.
RESULTS
The slice-selective
refocusing RF pulse envelopes of the PRESS sequences in Philips, Siemens and GE
3T scanners were quite different, as shown in Fig. 1. In the GE PRESS, the flip
angle of the refocusing pulse was set at 137° to improve the frequency profile shape. Numerical
simulations indicated that, in each of the Philips, Siemens and GE PRESS sequences,
the 2HG signal at short TE (e.g., ≤ 30 ms) was large but it was broad and thus not
very ideal for 2HG signal differentiation from neighboring resonances (spectra
not shown). In all cases, the 2HG signal varied extensively with changing TE
1 and TE
2, showing asymmetric dependence on TE
1 and TE
2 (Fig. 2). When normalized
to the signal at (TE
1, TE
2) = (12, 12) ms, the PRESS sequences of Philips,
Siemens and GE had temporal maxima of 77%, 85% and 81% at (TE
1, TE
2) = (32, 65),
(30, 71), and (22, 82) ms, respectively, ignoring T2 relaxation
effects. In-vitro and in-vivo experiments were carried out
using TE = 97 ms for the convenience of individual sites, whose subecho times
were (TE
1, TE
2) = (32, 65), (17, 80), and (26, 71) ms for Philips, Siemens and
GE, respectively. The 2HG signal agreed well between phantom experiment and volume-localized
simulation (Fig. 3a,b). The 2HG 2.25-ppm signals were large and narrow, with
the H3 and H3’ resonances attenuated. For comparison, spectra calculated with hard
pulses (without volume localization) were very different from phantom spectra
(Fig. 3c). Finally we tested the TE = 97 ms PRESS of the three vendors in
patients with IDH-mutated gliomas. In each case, a signal was clearly
discernible at 2.25 ppm (Fig. 4). The in-vivo spectra were well reproduced by
LCModel fits, resulting in negligible residuals at ~2.25 ppm (Residuals-1). When
2HG was removed from the basis set however, unfit residuals were observed at
~2.25 ppm in all three spectra (Residuals-2), indicating that 2HG was detected
with high selectivity. The 2HG CRLB was less than 10% in all cases.
DISCUSSION
This
study reports multi-site test of optimized long-TE approaches in the MR scanners
of three major vendors for detection of 2HG. Results show that the MRS methods
have the capability of providing 2HG measurement with good precision in all
three vendors. Since the RF pulses used are readily available in the vendor-supplied
protocols, the data acquisition methods are easily transferable to other sites.
The PRESS subecho times used for experiments were slightly different than
suggested by simulations. This may not be problematic since the 2HG signals do
not differ substantially between the simulation-suggested and experimental
subecho time sets. Use of a proper basis is rather critical for reliable
spectral analysis, as evidenced in Fig. 3. A major pitfall of this study is
that, due to inconsistency of experimental conditions for reference water
signal acquisition, the 2HG concentration is presented relative to the choline
level, which is substantially altered in tumors. Future study requires
standardization of the reference signal acquisition that will provide 2HG estimates
directly comparable between vendors and sites. Lastly, the long-TE 2HG MRS can
be easily extended to multi-voxel imaging with minimal interferences from
macromolecules and lipids.
CONCLUSION
Data
indicate that 2HG-optimized long-TE approaches perform well in the Philips,
Siemens and GE MR systems, giving rise to narrowing of the 2HG 2.25-ppm
multiplet and consequently conferring precise estimation of 2HG. The long-TE
MRS methods may therefore have the great potential for non-invasive
diagnosis/prognosis in IDH-mutated gliomas.
Acknowledgements
This
research was supported by a Cancer Prevention Research
Institute of Texas grant RP130427.References
1. Dang L, White DW, Gross S, et
al. Cancer-associated IDH1 mutations produce 2-hydroxyglutarate. Nature
2009;462:739-744.
2. Choi C, Ganji SK,
DeBerardinis RJ, et al. 2-hydroxyglutarate detection by magnetic resonance
spectroscopy in IDH-mutated patients with gliomas. Nat Med 2012;18:624-629.
3. Choi C, Ganji S, Hulsey K, et al. A
comparative study of short- and long-TE 1H MRS at 3 T for in vivo detection of
2-hydroxyglutarate in brain tumors. NMR Biomed 2013;26:1242-1250.