Ilaria Boscolo Galazzo1,2, Silvia Francesca Storti3, Anna Barnes1, Enrico De Vita4, Francesca Benedetta Pizzini2, John Duncan5, Ashley Groves1, Gloria Menegaz3, and Francesco Fraioli1
1Institute of Nuclear Medicine, University College London, London, United Kingdom, 2Department of Neuroradiology, University Hospital Verona, Verona, Italy, 3Department of Computer Science, University of Verona, Verona, Italy, 4Department of Brain Repair and Rehabilitation, UCL Institute of Neurology, London, United Kingdom, 5Department of Clinical and Experimental Epilepsy, UCL Institute of Neurology, London, United Kingdom
Synopsis
In this
study, we propose the assessment of resting-state brain networks (RSNs) using
Arterial Spin Labeling perfusion MRI as an alternative to the gold-standard
sequence represented by the Blood-oxygenation-level-dependent (BOLD) contrast. RSNs
have been derived by means of independent component analysis (ICA) and
spatially compared to literature networks. In addition, functional connectivity
changes in epileptic patients have been quantified in comparison to healthy
controls. The results demonstrated ASL suitability in
identifying RSNs, with a strong agreement with BOLD, and in detecting
functional alterations in pathological conditions.Introduction
Resting-state
networks (RSNs) and functional connectivity has been increased exploited to
investigate synchronous activity and identify abnormalities in different
pathologies, including epilepsy1. Most of the studies have been
based on blood-oxygenation-level-dependent (BOLD) contrast in combination with
spatial independent component analysis (ICA) to separate signals into maps of
covarying voxels2,3.Promising results have been recently achieved in
RSN analysis using Arterial Spin Labeling (ASL)4,5, which
demonstrated its ability to provide direct and quantitative measures of brain
physiology6. However, its wide application has been hampered by the
relatively low sensitivity and robustness to noise sources, which have to be properly
filtered when mapping resting-state fluctuations. In
this study, we aim to: 1) assess the ability of ASL combined with two
preprocessing pipelines in detecting RSNs derived from ICA compared to
literature networks; 2) quantify spatial RSNs in healthy controls (HC) and
epilepsy patients; 3) evaluate the temporal properties of the spatial independent
components (IC) for deriving measures of brain connectivity and identifying significant
pathological alterations.
Materials and Methods
Experimental protocol:Seven healthy volunteers
(32±6years) and seven patients (31±8years) with drug-resistant temporal epilepsy were scanned on a 3T PET/MR scanner (Biograph mMR) using 2D-EPI pulsed PICORE Q2TIPS ASL7(3.6x3.6x5mm3;19 slices;TI1/TIs/TI2:800/1200/1800ms;TR/TE:2860/17ms).
Four resting ASL runs of 100 volumes each were acquired 5min apart from one
another.
HC data analysis: data preprocessing on
HC was carried out with FSL tools, in particular two preprocessing pipelines
were applied for each subject before spatial component identification:1)Basic
pipeline3: each ASL run underwent head motion correction, non-brain
removal, spatial smoothing with a 5-mm Gaussian kernel and high-pass filtering
(100s);2)Advanced pipeline: the basic pipeline is followed by single-session spatial
ICA using MELODIC8 separately applied to each dataset. The main artefactual components were visually identified
and removed by linear regression, obtaining cleaned data.
For each HC, the four
preprocessed ASL runs (basic and advanced pipelines) were transformed in the 2-mm
MNI space and underwent network decomposition by means of group-ICA with multi-session
temporal concatenation. ICs were converted to z-statistic maps and
threshold at z=33. ICs representing
the main RSNs were identified according to the spatial distribution proposed in SOA and
compared to the RSN template from BOLD with 10 ICs3 by quantifying
the
degree of spatial similarity/overlap (Dice’s Coefficient [DSC]) and spatial
cross-correlation for each network (r-value)9.
Patients’
data analysis: for each patient, only the
advanced pipeline has been applied and cleaned datasets
underwent the same group-ICA procedure as for HC.
Functional connectivity analysis: the
mean time course of each RSN was extracted in all subjects and Pearson’s
correlation between all networks’ pairs was calculated
deriving matrices of brain connectivity. Connectivity
differences between controls and patients were tested by Wilcoxon rank-sum test (p<0.05).
Results
For HC, ICA decompositions on basic and advanced preprocessed data
revealed seven common RSNs: medial visual (VIS), default mode network (DMN),
cerebellum (CER), sensorimotor (SM), auditory (AUD), executive (EXE) and joint
right-left frontoparietal (FP). In terms of DSC, the results consistently
showed across subjects a good level of overlap with reference networks for VIS,
DMN, CER, AUD and FP which further increased with the application of the
advanced pipeline. The same networks presented an overall r-value>0.25, the
minimum value for classifying a good component from BOLD data
3 (Fig.1).DMN
maps are reported for a representative subject in Fig.2, where the good spatial
similarities with the BOLD template can be appreciated by using the advanced
pipeline (DSC=0.55;r-value=0.63).
Since subjects’ results consistently showed the improvement introduced
by the advanced pipeline, this was used for patient’ data, revealing the same
seven RSNs were present in this group except for CER which was not detected in
two patients (Fig.3).The mean matrices of correlations computed between
the seven RSN time-courses of both HC and patients are reported in Fig.4. The
statistical analysis revealed significant changes in connectivity between DMN
and CER, with a decreased pattern in patients vs HC (z-value=1.936,p=0.04), and
between VIS and FP, with an increased correlation between these areas in
patients (z-value=-2.025,p=0.038).
Discussion and Conclusion
In this study, we first demonstrated ASL is able to detect not only DMN but
all the different networks, with good level of overlap and correlation with the
corresponding reference BOLD ICs. Moreover, ICA on cleaned data allows detecting
more precisely RSNs, increasing their similarities. Second, the spatial
patterns are consistent with commonly reported networks, both for HC and
patients. Finally, functional connectivity analyses derived from ICA results
allow to map pathological changes, in particular the decreased patterns
involving DMN are in line with previous studies on temporal epilepsy and BOLD,
showing reduced connectivity between DMN and different areas as cerebellum,
temporal and frontal lobes
10.
Acknowledgements
No acknowledgement found.References
[1] Centeno et al, Frontiers in Neurology 2014 [2] Biswal et al, Magn
Reson Med 1995 [3] Smith et al, PNAS 2009 [4] Zhu et al, Plos One 2013 [5] Jann et al,
Neuroimage 2015 [6] Buxton et al, Neuroimage 2004 [7] Luh et al, Magn
Reson Med 1999 [8] Beckmann et al, IEEE Trans Med Imaging 2004 [9] Bright et al, Neuroimage 2015 [10] Mankinen
et al, Brain Res 2011