Miles E. Olsen1, Ethan K. Brodsky1, Jonathan A. Oler2, Marissa K. Riedel2, Eva M. Fekete2, Ned H. Kalin2, and Walter F. Block1
1Medical Physics, University of Wisconsin - Madison, Madison, WI, United States, 2Psychiatry, University of Wisconsin - Madison, Madison, WI, United States
Synopsis
We present a technique for rapidly aiming
interventional devices during prospective stereotaxy procedures. Our approach
enables accurate computational determination of trajectory guide orientation
and the true physical pivot point of frameless stereotaxy guides that mount on
the skull.
Historically, these neurosurgical tasks require
minutes per iterative cycle consisting of: scan, interpret image, adjust aim,
repeat – or no intraoperative imaging at all, relying on preoperative images
registered to stereotactic frame coordinates. Our rapid technique (~5 FPS) is
closer to the clinician’s preferred responsiveness of optical tracking of
devices in the OR (~30 FPS).
Purpose
The technique of
prospective stereotaxy [1] was developed for aiming a class of frameless
stereotaxy trajectory guides. Localizing commercial devices in MR-guided neurosurgery with prospective stereotaxy is achieved
through iteratively imaging and manipulating the device until it is deemed on
target, as in the ClearPoint system (MRI Interventions, Irvine, CA). This
process may take several minutes to complete. Compressed sensing improves imaging
performance by exploiting sparse image representations, sparse sampling
patterns, and novel reconstruction. We use these concepts to compute the
orientation of a trajectory guide with a frame rate 25x faster than our
previous real-time, Cartesian imaging based approach. We demonstrate our method’s
utility in a survival experiment of gene delivery designed to alter behavioral expression
of anxiety in 8 non-human primates over several months.
Methods
Brain cannulas are inserted
with sub-mm accuracy through a trajectory guide fixed to the skull, bypassing
the blood-brain-barrier. Preoperative MRI is used to determine a suitable
mounting point for the base of the guide such that the target falls within the
guide’s range of motion (a 30° cone, Fig. 1).
Intraoperative MRI is used during the
procedure to visually identify the target and pivot. Our previous real-time
approach [2] then imaged a plane above the brain and perpendicular to the
planned trajectory. The operator viewed those cross-sectional images of the stem
while moving the guide into alignment with the planned trajectory. Though much
faster than iterative approaches, performance is hindered by 1) slow frame
rates to generate high resolution images of the guide’s cross section and 2)
difficulties visually selecting the true geometric pivot with sub-mm accuracy. Instead
of imaging, our new approach acquires sets of 1D projections through the
alignment stem at various angles and offsets, as shown in Fig. 2.
Each 1D projection is correlated with the
known theoretical projection of the circularly symmetric alignment stem to find
its center location along the projection. These computed locations can be
configured into an overdetermined system of equations to find the orientation
of the guide (blue lines in Fig. 2) and indicate it to the operator. Lines
representing device orientation are recorded as the operator moves the guide to
three different alignments. All trajectories are constrained to pass through
the pivot point, so the 3D intersection of those lines is computed to yield
improved pivot point coordinates. The operator then aligns the guide with the
target by simply moving the computed point onto the green aim point (Fig. 3).
If the trajectory guide is aimed based on an
incorrect pivot, the tip of the device may not hit the target, as illustrated in
Fig. 4.
We demonstrate the method using a Navigus
trajectory guide (Medtronic, Minneapolis, MN) consisting of a pivoting ball
joint within a base that can be fixed to the skull over a burr hole [3]. Viral
vector containing a genetic payload was precisely delivered to the amygdala
using 2 infusions, one anterior and one posterior, in a study of gene therapy
to alter expression of anxiety. The technique has been used in 8 primate invivo
surgeries to accurately treat two locations within the central amygdala, an
obliquely oriented cylinder only 5 mm in length and 2 mm in diameter.
Results and Discussion
Each 1D projection
was acquired with 0.4 mm resolution. Sampling 18 angles at 2 offsets was found
to produce accurate, repeatable calculation of the device orientations. As each
1D MR experiment required only 5 ms, the device orientation could be calculated
at 5 frames/s, a considerable improvement over our 0.2 frames/s performance
using Cartesian imaging. The clear visualizaiton of
Gd-doped infusate is shown in Fig. 5.
Over 8 subjects, in the N=22 instances of
computing a pivot point, the total 3D separation between the manually selected
and computed points was 1.62 ± 0.90 mm, and the radial (perpendicular to
trajectory) separation was 0.67 ± 0.36 mm.
Our new approach eliminates error-prone manual
selection of the pivot. Solving for location with an overdetermined set of
equations allows for alignment with theoretical precision greater than the
image resolution while reducing the chances for operator error to affect
alignment.
Conclusions and Future Work
We have implemented a
system for rapidly and computationally identifying the true pivot point and
orientation within a trajectory guide. This improves the targeting process by
reducing errors that may arise from alignment stem tip uniformity and human interpretation
of MR images. The 25x improvement in frame rate eases the aiming process and may
be further increased as we experiment with using fewer projections.
Acknowledgements
The research was
supported by the National Research Service Award (NRSA) T32 EB011434. We also acknowledge
institutional support from GE Healthcare.References
[1] Truwit C and Liu H. Prospective
stereotaxy: a novel method of trajectory alignment using real-time image
guidance. JMRI. 2001;13(3):452–457.
[2] Grabow et al. Alteration of Molecular Neurochemistry: MRI-guided
Delivery of Viral Vectors to the Primate Amygdala. ISMRM. 2014 #0672.
[3] Hall W.; Liu H; Truwit C. Navigus
Trajectory Guide. Neurosurgery. 2000;46(2):502.