Anne Rijpma1,2, Marinette van der Graaf3,4, Olga Meulenbroek1,2, Marcel Olde Rikkert1,2, and Arend Heerschap3
1Geriatric Medicine, Radboud university medical center, Nijmegen, Netherlands, 2Radboud Alzheimer Centre, Donders Institute for Brain, Cognition and Behaviour, Radboud university medical center, Nijmegen, Netherlands, 3Radiology and Nuclear Medicine, Radboud university medical center, Nijmegen, Netherlands, 4Paediatrics, Radboud university medical center, Nijmegen, Netherlands
Synopsis
In this study we assessed phospholipid and
energy metabolism in patients with mild Alzheimer’s disease and healthy age-matched
control subjects by 3D 31P MRS imaging. Four brain regions were
investigated: left and right hippocampus, anterior cingulate cortex, and
retrosplenial cortex. Disease specific differences as well as differences
between brain regions were found. Background
In vivo studies in Alzheimer’s Disease (AD) have
shown reduced glucose uptake in the retrosplenial cortex (RSC), as measured by
FDG-PET
1, and altered resting state activity in the default mode
network of the RSC, mediotemporal and frontal brain regions, as measured by
fMRI
2. Additionally, post-mortem and
in vitro studies indicate alterations in membrane phospholipid
metabolism
3 as well as in basic energy mechanisms (e.g. creatine
kinase (CK) activity
4) in AD patients. Both phospholipid and energy
metabolism can be investigated
in vivo by phosphorus MR Spectrocopy (
31P
MRS). Previous
31P MRS studies
5,6,7 have so far provided
inconclusive results, due to variation in disease stage and medication status
of AD patients, and differences in investigated brain regions and control groups.
In addition, these studies were often hampered by low spectral resolution and
small sample sizes.
Purpose
To assess phospholipid and energy metabolism in
multiple brain regions in mild AD patients and healthy age-matched control
subjects by 3D
31P MRS imaging.
Methods
31P MRSI was performed
in 31 drug-naïve mild AD patients (MMSE ≥20; 73.5±6.9 [mean±SD] yrs) and 31
age- and gender-matched controls (73.5±6.3 yrs). Whole brain
31P-MRSI
data was obtained on a Siemens Magnetom Trio 3T system with a dual-tuned
1H/
31P
volume head coil (Rapid) and a 3D pulse-acquire sequence with the following
parameter values: TR=2000 ms, TE=0.10 ms, 40° flip-angle, NA=4, WALTZ4 proton
decoupling, nominal voxel size=16.25x16.25x16.25mm, TA=13:08 min. Resonances in MR spectra
from four regions of interest (ROI; left and right hippocampus, HL and HR; anterior
cingulate cortex, ACC; and RSC) were fitted using Metabolite Report (Siemens) (Figure
1), resulting in metabolite levels of phosphocholine (PCho),phosphoethanolamine
(PEtn), glycerophosphocholine (GPCho), glycerophosphoethanolamine (GPEtn),
inorganic phosphate (Pi), phosphocreatine (PCr), nicotinamide adenine
dinucleotide (NAD(H)) and alpha, beta and gamma adenosine triphosphate (a/b/yATP).
For all metabolites the signal percentage with respect to the total phosphorus
signal was calculated. Both a quantitative
evaluation of the fitting results (Cramer–Rao lower bound ≤30%) and a visual
quality control (independently by two spectroscopists) were performed. Only
metabolites that passed both quality checks were included in the statistical
analyses. Level of phosphomonoesters (PME) was calculated as the sum of PCh and PEth, phosphodiesters
(PDE) as the sum of GPCh and GPEth, and total ATP (tATP) as the sum of aATP,
bATP and yATP. In addition, we calculated pH and ratios for phosphomonoesters
to phosphodiesters (PME/PDE as well as PEth/GPEth and PCh/GPCh), and PCr to Pi.
Group differences were analyzed using a mixed model with group (AD or control),
sex, and brain region as fixed factors, considering brain region as a within
subject factor, and adjusting for age.
Results
Quality control led to the rejection of 3-20% of metabolite fits for phospholipid
metabolites and NAD(H). Excellent fits (<2% rejected) for all other
metabolites was achieved. An interaction between group and brain region was
found for PCr, showing that levels of PCr were higher in mild AD patients
compared with healthy control (HC) subjects in the RSC (LS mean difference=0.86,
SEM=0.29 [p=0.004]) and left (LS mean difference=1.52, SEM=0.52 [p=0.005]) and
right hippocampus (LS mean difference=1.47, SEM=0.38 [p<0.001]), but not in
the ACC (Figure 2A). A main effect of group was found for PCr/Pi (AD>HC; LS
mean difference=0.22, SEM=0.11 [p=0.046]; Figure 2B) and pH (AD>HC; LS mean
difference=0.008, SEM=0.004 [p=0.032]; Figure 2C). No effect of group was found
for Pi, NAD(H), t/a/b/yATP or any of the phospholipid compounds measured. A
main effect of brain region was found for PEth, PDE, GPEtn, GPCh, PME/PDE,
PEth/GPEth, PCh/GPCh, PCr/Pi, Pi, t/a/b/yATP, NAD(H), and pH.
Discussion and conclusion
To the best of our knowledge, this is the
largest
31P MRS study performed in AD patients. By using 3D MRSI we
were able to measure multiple brain regions simultaneously and provide both
disease specific as well as regional information. Most phospholipid compounds
and all high energy phosphates displayed regional variation. This may be caused
by true intra-cellular metabolic differences
between brain regions, or arise from differences in tissue composition. The
differences in PCr and pH found between AD patients and healthy aged controls
indicate a redistribution of metabolites involved in the CK reaction
equilibrium [K = PCr∙ADP∙H+ / Cr∙ATP]. Taken together with changes
in PCr/Pi, this could reflect altered energy metabolism in AD, or alternatively,
be a consequence of morphological differences (altered ratio of neurons to glia
cells, e.g. gliosis).
Acknowledgements
No acknowledgement found.References
1Nestor, et al. 2003, Eur J Neurosci 18(9); 2Greicius,
et al. 2004, PNAS 101(13); 3Nitsch,
et al. 1992, PNAS 89(5); 4Aksenov, et al. 2000, J Neurochem 74(6); 5Pettegrew,
et al. 1994, Neurobiol Aging 15(1); 6Forlenza,
et al. 2005, Psychopharmacology 180(2); 7Mandal, et al. 2012, J Alz
Dis 29;