Synopsis
We propose a novel approach to data acquisition and
image reconstruction that achieves high-quality in vivo whole-brain human diffusion imaging at (660 µm)3
resolution in 25 minutes. The approach
uses a powerful acquisition strategy (generalized SLIce Dithered
Enhanced Resolution Simultaneous MultiSlice, or
gSlider-SMS) that enables
high-resolution whole-brain imaging in 25 minutes (64 diffusion weightings + 7
b=0 images), but the resulting images suffer from low SNR without
averaging. To address the SNR problem,
we utilize a regularized reconstruction/denoising approach that leverages the
shared spatial structure of different diffusion images. In vivo
results demonstrate the effectiveness of this approach.Purpose
It is extremely challenging to
acquire whole-brain in
vivo diffusion
weighted images (DWIs) with sub-millimeter resolution using
traditional approaches. This work proposes and evaluates a novel
approach to diffusion MRI that can acquire 71 whole-brain DWIs (64
diffusion weightings + 7 b=0 images) at (660 µm)3
resolution in 25 minutes. Our approach is based on a novel
generalization [1] of the previous Slider-SMS approach [2], combined
with a regularized reconstruction method that has been demonstrated
to substantially improve the SNR in both healthy [3] and injured [4]
tissues with a minimal loss of spatial resolution.
Theory
The
previous Slider-SMS acquisition strategy for diffusion MRI [2]
combines multiple novel fast imaging technologies to achieve
high-resolution whole-brain imaging:
$$$\bullet$$$Blipped CAIPI [5] was used to
enable SNR-efficient simultaneous imaging of multiple slices.
$$$\bullet$$$Thick-slice super-resolution
techniques [6] were used to increase resolution along the slice
dimension. Thick-slice super-resolution techniques acquire
overlapping thick slices, and then solve a linear system of
equations to estimate the corresponding thin slices of interest.
This is advantageous because thin slices can be recovered from an
acquisition that exploits the higher SNR-efficiency of 3D volume
encoding.
While
Slider-SMS was effective at enabling high-resolution whole-brain
diffusion MRI [2], it still suffers from blurring due to the inherent
ill-conditioning of the thick-slice super-resolution inverse problem,
which itself results from the large coherence between the encoding
functions of the overlapping thick-slice acquisition. The novel
gSlider-SMS acquisition approach [1] uses the same Blipped CAIPI and
thick-slice super-resolution approaches as Slider-SMS, except that
the excitation RF pulse is modified so that each thick slice has a
specially-designed non-uniform phase profile along the slice
dimension, which serves as an additional form of RF encoding. This
RF phase encoding has the effect of substantially reducing the
coherence between the shifted overlapping thick-slice encoding
functions, which improves the conditioning of the inverse problem and
enables higher-fidelity reconstruction.
While
gSlider-SMS is very SNR-efficient, the extremely small isotropic
voxel sizes mean that SNR is still a limiting factor for DWIs
acquired with high b-values.
To address this issue, we employ a variation of a previous
regularized reconstruction method [3,4] that uses phase modeling to
regain the resolution lost from partial Fourier acquisition, and
simultaneously uses the structural similarity between different DWIs
to reduce noise perturbation while preserving high-resolution image
features.
Methods
Whole-brain
gSlider-SMS DWI data was acquired at 660 µm isotropic resolution
over a 220×118×151.8 mm FOV, with 7 b=0
images and 64 DWIs with b=1,500
s/mm2.
Each average was acquired in 25 minutes, and three averages were
acquired to provide a gold standard reference.
The
acquisition used thick slices (5× larger than each thin slice) with
5 different RF encoding pulses, a multiband factor of 2, and 6/8ths
partial Fourier encoding. The thick slices were first reconstructed
using slice-GRAPPA reconstruction [7]. Subsequently, gSlider
reconstruction, partial Fourier reconstruction, and denoising were
performed simultaneously by solving
$$\{\hat{\mathbf{p}},\hat{\boldsymbol{\phi}}\} =
\arg\min_{\mathbf{p},\boldsymbol{\phi}}\|\mathbf{b}- \mathbf{G}(
\boldsymbol{\phi}\odot\mathbf{A}\mathbf{p})\|_2^2+\lambda_1
R(\boldsymbol{\phi}) + \lambda_2 J(\mathbf{p})
$$
where $$$\mathbf{b}$$$
is the vector of
complex images obtained after slice-GRAPPA reconstruction,
$$$\mathbf{p}$$$ is the unknown
vector of DWI amplitudes (real-valued and nonnegative),
$$$\mathbf{A}$$$ is the matrix
modeling the thick-slice and RF encoded gSlider acquisition,
$$$\boldsymbol{\phi}$$$ is the unknown phase
of each measured thick slice (phase is not consistent in diffusion
MRI), and
$$$\mathbf{G}$$$ is the matrix
modeling the in-plane point-spread function of partial Fourier
acquisition. The regularization penalty
$$$R(\cdot)$$$ encourages
$$$\boldsymbol{\phi}$$$ to be smooth within each slice [8,9], while the $$$J(\cdot)$$$ penalty
uses a Huber function to impose that $$$\mathbf{p}$$$
is smooth, but has
edge structures that are shared between different DWIs [3,4,10].
Optimization is performed using a majorize-minimize approach that
alternates between estimating
$$$\mathbf{p}$$$ and
$$$\boldsymbol{\phi}$$$.
Results
Figure
1 shows an example of the substantial image-domain SNR-enhancement
that is achievable using SNR-enhancing regularized reconstruction.
Figure 2 shows that the SNR-enhancement also has a major impact on
quantitative diffusion parameter estimation. Specifically,
single-average data without SNR-enhancing regularization yields noisy
biased parameter estimates, while single-average data with
SNR-enhancing regularization yields similar results to the
three-average reference data. As shown in Fig. 3, SNR-enhancing
regularization also enables high-quality orientation estimation that
is sensitive enough to detect the coherent orientation within gray
matter.
Discussion and Conclusions
We
proposed a novel acquisition and reconstruction strategy that uses
gSlider-SMS together with regularized reconstruction to achieve a
dramatic gain in SNR-efficiency relative to conventional 2D diffusion
acquisition. We have leveraged these advances in SNR-efficiency to
achieve a (660 µm)
3
resolution whole-brain quantitative diffusion MRI acquisition in 25
minutes, which we believe will prove useful across the full range of
in vivo
human diffusion MRI applications.
Acknowledgements
This
work was supported in part by NSF CAREER award CCF-1350563 and NIH
grants R01-NS089212, R24-MH106096, and R01-EB019437.References
[1]
K. Setsompop, J. Stockmann, Q. Fan, T. Witzel, L. L. Wald.
“Generalized SLIce
Dithered Enhanced Resolution Simultaneous MultiSlice (gSlider-SMS) to
increase volume encoding, SNR and partition profile fidelity in
high-resolution diffusion imaging.”
Proc ISMRM
2016.
[2]
K. Setsompop, B. Bilgic, A. Nummenmaa, Q. Fan, S. F. Cauley, S.
Huang, I. Chatnuntawech, Y. Rathi, T. Witzel, L. L. Wald. “SLIce
Dithered Enhanced Resolution Simultaneous MultiSlice (SLIDER-SMS) for
high resolution (700 um) diffusion imaging of the human brain.”
Proc ISMRM
2015, p. 339.
[3]
J. P. Haldar, V. J. Wedeen, M. Nezamzadeh, G. Dai, M. W. Weiner, N.
Schuff, Z.-P. Liang. “Improved Diffusion Imaging through
SNR-Enhancing Joint Reconstruction.” Magn
Reson Med 69:277-289,
2013.
[4]
J. H. Kim, S.-K. Song, J. P. Haldar. “Signal-to-Noise
Ratio-Enhancing Joint Reconstruction for Improved Diffusion Imaging of Mouse
Spinal Cord White Matter Injury.” Magn
Reson Med, Early
View. DOI: 10.1002/mrm.25691
[5]
K. Setsompop, B. A. Gagoski, J. R. Polimeni, T. Witzel, V. J. Wedeen,
L. L. Wald. “Blipped-controlled aliasing in parallel imaging for
simultaneous multislice echo planar imaging with reduced g-factor
penalty.” Magn
Reson Med 67:1210-1224,
2012.
[6]
H. Greenspan. “Super-resolution in medical imaging.” Comput
J 52:43-63, 2009.
[7]
S. F. Cauley, J. R. Polimeni, H. Bhat, L. L. Wald, K. Setsompop.
“Interslice leakage artifact reduction technique for simultaneous
multislice acquisitions.” Magn
Reson Med 72:93-102,
2014.
[8]
J. P. Haldar, Z. Wang, G. Popescu, Z.-P. Liang. “Deconvolved
spatial light interference microscopy for live cell imaging.” IEEE
Trans Biomed Eng
58:2489-2497, 2011.
[9]
F. Zhao, D. C. Noll, J. F. Nielsen, J. A. Fessler. “Separate
magnitude and phase regularization via compressed sensing.” IEEE
Trans Med Imaging
32:1713-1723, 2012.
[10]
J. P. Haldar, Z.-P. Liang. “Joint reconstruction of noisy
high-resolution MR image sequences.” IEEE
Int Symp Biomed Imaging 2008,
pp. 752-755.