Daniel J Cox1,2, Hamied A Haroon2, Daniela Montaldi1, and Laura M Parkes2
1School of Psychological Sciences, University of Manchester, Manchester, United Kingdom, 2Centre for Imaging Sciences, University of Manchester, Manchester, United Kingdom
Synopsis
Alterations to hippocampal
microstructure may precede gross volumetric changes in ageing, and
these changes may occur preferentially in different hippocampal
subfields. We investigated both established (FA and mADC) and novel
(DOC) measurements of diffusion in these regions, in addition to
volume, in order to determine where age-related changes occurred. The
results showed changes across the majority of subfields for mADC and
FA, but only in left CA 2/3 for DOC measures 1, 3 and >3. We
suggest this could be related to differential degradation of
particular cellular structures in these regions.Introduction
As normal healthy aging occurs, research has shown that the hippocampus
undergoes both macro and microstructural changes
1,2. Whilst many
studies investigate gross volumetric or microstructural
changes across the hippocampus as a whole, it is likely that there is
a degree of separation between subfields in terms of
microstructure
3. We investigated age-related changes in established
(fractional anisotropy (FA) and mean apparent diffusion coefficient
(mADC)) and novel (diffusion orientation complexity (DOC)) measures
of diffusion, in addition to volume, across the cornu ammonis (CA)
subfields. We hypothesised that measures of hippocampal microstructure will change with age, and that there will be a differentiation between subfields in this change which may not be apparent from volumetric analysis.
Methods
34 healthy volunteers
participated in the study, which was approved by a local NHS research
ethics committee. A 3T Philips Achieva system with an 8-element head
coil was used to collect data. Both structural T1 weighted
(0.94x0.94x1mm) and High Angle Resolution Diffusion Imaging (HARDI)
data (TE=59ms, matrix 128x128, slice thickness 2.1mm, 60 contiguous
slices, in-plane resolution 1.875x1.875mm, 43 non-collinear diffusion
sensitization directions, b=1200s/mm2, 1 at b=0, cardiac gating) were
collected. Diffusion data was corrected for susceptibility and eddy
current induced distortion4.
In-house software calculated voxel-wise probability maps (fig 1)5 for n
number of fibre orientations (1, 2, 3 or greater than 3,
which are referred to as DOC 1, 2, 3 and >3 respectively).
All T1-weighted images were
segmented using the cortical parcellation and hippocampal subfield
(v5.33)6
segmentation pipelines available in Freesurfer. Hippocampal subfields
were transformed into native space using the inverse transform
provided by Freesurfer, and thresholded so only voxels having at least
51% probability of belonging to a subfield and 75% probability for
consisting of grey matter were included (fig 2). These regions were then
registered into diffusion space for each subject. Subfield volumes were also normalised to intracranial volume for each subject. 4
hippocampal segmentations failed or did not register correctly, so
the final dataset used for this study totalled 30 subjects (age 18-30
(n15) and 60-82 (n15), mean age 48.1 ± 26.8).
Image analysis was performed in
SPM12 using MarsBaR (v0.437) to extract data values for left and right
hippocampal CA regions (CA1, CA2-3 and CA 4-dentate gyrus (DG)).
Independent t-test analyses were then performed in SPSS 22 on the
data to determine in which subfields age-related volumetric or
diffusion changes occurred.
Results
All results given are corrected
for multiple comparisons
8 and are p<0.05.
Independent sample t-tests were used to investigate volume change
between age groups across all subfields, though no significant
results were found after correction. Next, additional t-test analyses
were performed to examine age-related differences for FA, mADC and
DOC in each subfield. FA and mADC showed significant age-related
changes between age groups in all subfields except for left CA1 and
right CA1/CA2-3 for FA, with older adults showing decreased FA and
increased mADC overall. T-tests also showed significant decreases to DOC1,
and increases to DOC3 and DOC>3 in left CA 2-3 only (figs 3 and 4). These
results suggest that measures of diffusivity may be more sensitive to
age-related physiological changes in hippocampal subfields than gross volume.
Discussion
The results of this study support our hypotheses and suggest that novel measures of tissue
microstructure (such as DOC) may provide additional information to
that given by current measures. They may also act as sensitive
markers of age-related neurophysiological decline in the hippocampus
compared to tissue atrophy, as shown by highlighting
microstructural changes in specific hippocampal subfields. This may be because particular cellular structures (for example, pyramidal neurons) degrade to a greater extent in certain subregions during aging. These findings highlight the need for further investigation into this
effect, particularly with regards to cognitive measures of
recognition memory which have been shown to be correlated with
particular subfields.
Acknowledgements
No acknowledgement found.References
Wisse, L. et al (2014)
'Hippocampal subfield volumes at 7T in early Alzheimer's disease and
normal aging.', Neurobiology of Aging, vol. 35 no. 9 pp.
2039-45
Cox, D. J. et al (2015)
'Quantification of age-related hippocampal microstructure changes and
recollection memory decline', Proceedings of the Organisation for
Human brain Mapping, Honolulu, Hawaii poster number 1748
Pereira, J. B. et al
(2014) 'Regional vulnerability of hippocampal subfields to aging
measured by structural and diffusion MRI' Hippocampus, vol.
24 no. 4 pp. 403 - 414
Embleton, K. E. et al.
(2010) ‘Distortion correction for diffusion-weighted MRI
Tractography and fMRI in the temporal lobes’, Human Brain
Mapping, vol. 31 no.10 pp. 1570-1587
Haroon, H et al. (2010)
'Probabilistic Quantification of Microstructural Complexity in
Cortical and Subcortical Regions' Proceedings of the
Organisation for Human Brain Mapping, Barcelona, Spain poster number
829 Wh-AM
Van Leemput, K et al
(2009) 'Automated Segmentation of Hippocampal Subfields from
Ultra-High Resolution In Vivo MRI', Hippocampus, vol. 19, no.
6 pp. 549-557
Brett, M et al. (2002)
'Region of interest analysis using an SPM toolbox', 8th
International Conference on Functional Mapping of the Human
Brain, Sendai, Japan
Benjamini, Y., and Y.
Hochberg. (1995) ‘Controlling the false discovery rate: a practical
and powerful approach to multiple testing’, Journal of the
Royal Statistical Society B, 57 pp. 289-300