Chencai Wang1, Chaohsiung Hsu1, Stephanie Wolohan1, and Yung-Ya Lin1
1Department of Chemistry and Biochemistry, UCLA, Los Angeles, CA, United States
Synopsis
A general indirect-detection and spin-amplification
scheme has been developed to enhance the sensitivity of heteronuclear MRS
and MRI based on dynamic
instability of the solvent proton magnetization under collective feedback
fields of radiation damping and the distant dipolar field. The heteronuclear solute spins are first detected by the
solvent proton spins through various magnetization transfer mechanisms and
serve as small “input” signals to perturb the solvent proton magnetization,
which is prepared in an unstable state. The weakly detected signal is then
amplified through subsequent nonlinear evolution of the solvent proton
magnetization to achieve 10x SNR improvement for 13C MRS and MRI.Purpose
Low sensitivity is particularly problematic in
heteronuclear MRI, where insensitive and/or dilute heteronuclear spins are
detected. A general spin amplification scheme was developed to enhance the
sensitivity of heteronuclear spins based on dynamic instability of the solvent
magnetization under collective feedback fields. The heteronuclear solute spins
are first detected by the solvent proton spins through various magnetization
transfer mechanisms and serve as small “input” signals to perturb the solvent
proton magnetization, which is prepared in an unstable state. The weakly
detected signal is then amplified through subsequent nonlinear evolution of the
solvent proton magnetization. By manipulating bulk solvent proton spins near
the threshold of instability to detect dilute heteronuclear solute spins, sensitivity and signal-to-noise ratios (SNR) of the heteronuclear
MR spectroscopy and imaging can be markedly improved.
Methods
This general indirect-detection and spin-amplification scheme (Fig. 1) has
been developed to amplify indirectly detected heteronuclear solute signals.
Low-gyromagnetic ratio nuclei can be detected through the large solvent 1H
magnetization by the distant dipolar field (DDF) [1,2]. As shown in Fig. 1, the
modulated 1H transverse magnetization precesses under the DDF
created by the spatially modulated 13C longitudinal magnetization,
generating an echo in the 1H solvent magnetization that carries
information about the 13C spins. Recently discovered self-refocusing
of dephased solvent magnetization due to the joint action of radiation damping
and the DDF [2] is exploited to enhance the indirectly detected echo signal.
The extreme sensitivity of the first and largest self-refocused echo's phase
and amplitude to the phase and amplitude of the initial triggering
magnetization (here, the indirectly detected signal) suggests that the
nonlinear spin dynamics can serve as a high-gain spin amplifier to enhance the
small initial magnetization transferred to the solvent from the dilute 13C
solute spins.
This general spin
amplification scheme is shown here to amplify indirectly detected heteronuclear
solute signals. Low-gyromagnetic ratio nuclei can be detected through the large
1H solvent magnetization by the distant dipolar field (DDF) [1,2].
As shown in Fig. 1 (pulse sequence at top, a+b), the modulated 1H
transverse magnetization precesses under the DDF created by the spatially
modulated 13C longitudinal magnetization, generating an echo in the 1H
solvent magnetization that carries information about the 13C spins.
Recently discovered self-refocusing of dephased solvent magnetization due to
the joint action of radiation damping and the DDF [3] is exploited to enhance
the indirectly detected echo signal. The extreme sensitivity of the first and
largest self-refocused echo's phase and amplitude to the phase and amplitude of
the initial triggering magnetization (here, the indirectly detected signal)
suggests that the nonlinear spin dynamics can serve as a high-gain spin
amplifier to enhance the small initial magnetization transferred to the solvent
from the dilute 13C solute spins. The resulting SNR of the amplified
indirectly detected echo signal, e.g.,
10% 2-13C acetone solution, is improved by ~3-4x (Fig. 2b) compared to
without amplification (Fig. 2a, DDF only).
Results: C13 MRS
The amplification factor can be further
improved by controlling the nonlinear spin evolution under the feedback fields.
For example, if the
1H pulse flip angle >90°, the instability of the inverted net
1H
longitudinal magnetization under radiation damping aids in refocusing more
1H
transverse magnetization. The resulting SNR is enhanced by an additional 4x, as
demonstrated on U-
13C glucose (Fig. 3). Moreover, field
inhomogeneity or weak continuous gradients may also be exploited to accelerate
the self-refocusing process [3] and increase SNR by more than 10x overall (Fig.
2c).
Results: 13C MRI
Application of this approach
to
13C MRI is shown in Fig. 4 and Fig. 5 for a K
13CN phantom
sample and
in vivo carrot stem,
respectively.
Conclusion
Sensitivity enhancement by the dynamic
instability of solvent proton magnetization represents a new direction for
surmounting a long-standing weakness of poor sensitivity in heteronuclear
MRS and MRI.
Acknowledgements
This work
was supported by the Camille and Henry Dreyfus Foundation (TC-05-053), National
Science Foundation (DMS-0833863, CHE-1112574, and CHE-1416598), Hirshberg
Foundation for Pancreatic Cancer Research, and Taiwan Ministry of Science and
Technology (NSC 100-2113-M-002-008, NSC 101-2113-M-002-018, and MOST
103-2923-M-002-006).References
[1] R. Bowtell, J. Magn. Reson.
100, 1 (1992)
[2] Warren et al. J. Chem. Phys.
108, 1313 (1998)
[3] Y.-Y. Lin et al. Science 290,
118 (2000).