A permanent magnet based low-field MRI system provides portability and affordability. However, the quality of the image is low due to a low signal-to-noise ratio (SNR). We propose a new deep learning structure which effectively integrates denoising-networks end-to-end to super-resolution-networks, to transfer the rich information available from one-off experimental imaging from a mid-field MRI scanner (1.5T) to the lower-quality data from a portable system. The procedure uses matched pairs to learn mappings from low-quality to the corresponding high-quality images. Using the proposed method, the quality and resolution of an image from a low-field MRI system is significantly improved.
Low-field MRI systems using permanent magnet arrays offer portability with affordability[1-2]. However, the field strength is relatively low which results in a low signal-to-noise ratio (SNR), and thus a low image quality. Here, we propose a new deep learning structure, which effectively integrates denoising-networks end-to-end to super-resolution-networks, to transfer the rich information available from one-off experimental imaging from mid-field MRI scanners (1.5T) to the lower-quality data from portable systems. We propose to use matched pairs to learn mappings from low-quality to the corresponding high-quality images.
Deep-neural-network(DNN) has been applied to single-image super-resolution[3-9]. A direct application of super-resolution on noisy images leads to inevitable magnified noises and distortions. Denoising is necessary before super-resolving images. In[10], convolutional-neural-network(CNN) was used to yield residuals, obtaining superior performance over other denoisers. End-to-end networks for jointly denoising and super-resolution were applied to restore natural images[11]. However, they are complexed and computationally expensive. For MRI images, the diversity between an image-pair is low, and it allows multiple scans of the same subject. The available networks are unnecessarily complicated, which could result in non-convergence or overfitting to training data.
MATERIALS & METHODS
We propose a simpler and more targeted model (shown in Fig.1(a)) for a quality transformation of low-field MRI images. It consists of a denoising-branch with 10 denoising-blocks and a super-resolution-branch with 16 super-resolution-blocks, bridged by a transpose-convolutional-layer. The number of parameters is half of that of EDSR[9]. A loss function in (1) (Fig.1(b)) which consists of a denoising-term and a super-resolution-term was used to drive the learning. Term-1 is the weighted difference of the low-resolution noise-free-image, ˆILR (ˆILR=IN−ˆN, at the exit of denoising-branch), and the r-time down-sampled high-quality image, IHR/r.
In Fig.1(a), each denoising-branch consists of two convolutions, two batch-normalization, an activation function (rectified-linear-unit (ReLU)), and an element-wise summation, with the size of convolution kernel, stride, and padding labeled. Instead of explicitly calculating the noise-residual of images[10], a long skip-connection was used as the residual-yielding-process internally to obtain ˆILR. Thus, the networks can be trained through Term-1 in (1) using intermedium-predicted images rather than noise patterns. In Fig.1(a), following the denoising-branch, transpose-convolutional-layer up-samples the matrix r-time for further super-revolving. The super-resolution-branch is similar to the denoising-branch without batch-normalization because batch-normalization does not favor super-resolving fine features or maintain original contrast levels[9]. Skip-connection was applied to this branch. Super-resolution-branch outputs ˆIr× and the difference between ˆIr× and the high-quality image, ˆIHR, forms Term-2 in (1).
To train the network, 1000 high-quality images (1.5T, Siemens, 240×240pixels) were downloaded[12] and the corresponding low-field low-quality images were generated based on the Halbach-array-based low-field MRI system (68mT)[2]. An encoding term, Cq(r)e−i2πγB0t, was used from the signal equation Sq(t)=∫VCq(r)e−i2πγB0tm(r)dr to generate low-field images where Cq(r) is the sensitivity of the qth coil, B0 is the spatial encoding magnetic field. The resolution of the image is determined by the pattern of B0[13]. It is down-sampled r-time. Gaussian-white-noise with a deviation of σsigma was added to the signal to obtain noisy images. When σsigma=−20dB, the standard deviation of the noise-residual-image (σ) is 0.1. Both the high-quality images (Fig.2(a)) and the noisy low-resolution ones (Fig.2(b)) from the low-field system were fed to the network for training.
RESULTS
Peak-SNR(PSNR) and structure-similarity-index(SSIM) were used to evaluate the quality of the reconstructed images. Fig.2(c) shows the reconstructed images using different numbers of training pairs (n) and Fig.2(d) shows the average PSNR of the tested images (σ=0.1) versus n. As shown, the quality and resolution of the images are significantly improved by the proposed network when it is trained sufficiently. The PSNR and SSIM are about 22 and 0.700, respectively when n=700, which takes approximately two hours (GPU: 4×11GB NVIDIA GTX1080Ti). Moreover, Fig.3 shows the reconstructed images with super-resolution without denoising. As shown, super-resolution does not suppress the noise of the images but introducing distortions.DISCUSSION & CONCLUSION
Here, a deep learning structure, which is an end-to-end effective integration of denoising-networks and super-resolution-deep-networks, is proposed to transfer low-quality noisy images from a low-field system to high-quality images. It is successfully demonstrated using simulated data from a Halbach-array-based low-field MRI system. Next, scanned images will be used to test the proposed technique where practical situations, e.g. real noise and a relative location mismatch between the images in a pair, will be taken into consideration.