Apurva Shah1, Shweta Prasad2, Santosh Dash3, Jitender Saini4, Pramod Kumar Pal3, and Madhura Ingalhalikar1
1Symbiosis Centre of Medical Image Analysis, Symbiosis International University, Pune, India, 2Department of Clinical Neurosciences and Neurology, National Institute of Mental Health and Neurosciences, Bangalore, India, 3Department of Neurology, National Institute of Mental Health and Neurosciences, Bangalore, India, 4Department of Neuroimaging & Interventional Radiology, National Institute of Mental Health and Neurosciences, Bangalore, India
Synopsis
Multiple
system atrophy with cerebellar features (MSA-C) is a distinct subtype
of MSA characterized by predominant cerebellar symptoms. Neuroimaging
studies have demonstrated cerebellar abnormalities; however,
abnormality of structural connectivity of the motor subnetwork has
not been studied and this study aims to investigate this aspect. We
observed impairment in the structural segregation, integration and
network resilience with significantly
reduced nodal strength and connectivity in several cerebellar as well
as non-cerebellar regions that correlate with UMSARS scores. Our
findings provide
definitive evidence of abnormalities that may be causally implicated
in the motor features of cerebellar dysfunction and Parkinsonism
observed in MSA-C.
Introduction
Multiple
system atrophy (MSA) is a sporadic, neurodegenerative disorder
characterized by available combination of progressive autonomic
dysfunction, parkinsonism, cerebellar and pyramidal features1.
MSA can be categorized based on the predominant motor symptoms as MSA
with predominant parkinsonism (MSA-P) and
MSA with predominant cerebellardysfunction (MSA-C)2.
MSA-C represents a distinct motor subtype of MSA, and is
characterized by gaitataxia, limbataxia, scanning dysarthria, and
cerebellar oculomotor dysfunction in addition to autonomicdysfunction
and parkinsonism3.
This
work focuses on the motor features of MSA-C and hypothesizes that
patients with MSA-C would demonstrate significantly higher
abnormality in the cerebellar network in comparison to the basal
ganglia network. This subnetwork comprising of the precentral cortex,
basal ganglia, thalamus, ventral diencephalon and cerebellum has been
previously utilized in connectivity-based studies in Parkinson’s
disease4,5.
Method
All
subjects (23 MSA-C, 25 HC, age and gender matched) were scanned on a
3T Philips Achieva MRI scanner using a 32-channel head coil. 3D-T1
structural image with high resolution were obtained with
echo-time(TE)=3.7ms, repetition-time(TR)=8.1ms,
field-of-view(FOV)=256x256x155mm, slice-thickness=1mm,
voxel-size=1x1x1mm, sense-factor=3.5, acquisition matrix=256x256,
flip-angle=80.
Diffusion imaging(DWI) were acquired using a single-shot spin-echo,
echo-planner sequence in axial section with TE=62ms. TR=8783ms,
FOV=224x224mm, voxel-size=1.75x1.75x2mm; diffusion gradient
direction=15, b-value=1000s/mm2
and single b=0s/mm2
image. To obtain complete connectome and determine the connectivity
from various cerebellar nodes, two atlases Desikan atlas from
Freesurfer-6.0(http://surfer.nmr.mgh.harvard.edu) and AAL atlas were
fused to delineate the complete brain and multiple region of interest
(ROIs) within cerebellum (from AAL). Using
FSL-5.0.9(https://fsl.fmrib.ox.ac.uk), probabilistic tractography6
was implemented to track fibers from each node to every other node.
Based on hypothesis of differences in the motor subnetwork, we
extracted 38 ROIs to create a 38*38 subnetwork as shown in Figure-1.
The ROIs selected included bilateral pre-central cortex, basal
ganglia, thalamus, ventral diencephalon and cerebellum. Global, nodal
measures were computed and analyzed for group difference using
MANCOVAN model while co-varying for age and gender and performed
False Discovery Rate(FDR) with significant q-value<0.05. Edge-wise
analysis was performed using NBS for 10000 permutation with
significant p-value<0.01. Further, global, nodal and edge strength
were correlated with duration of illness, total-UMSARS and motor
component scores. Pearson’s correlation was computed with age,
gender and cerebellum volumes as co-variates and the significance
threshold was maintained at p-value<0.05.
Results
Significant
decrease in density (corrected p-value<0.01), transitivity
(corrected p-value<0.01), characteristic path length (corrected
p-value<0.01) and clustering coefficient (corrected p-value<0.01)
was observed in motor subnetwork of patients with MSA-C when compared
to HC. Several
regions with significantly reduced nodal strength within the motor
subnetwork were observed in patients with MSA-C in comparison to HC
(Figure-1). Edge-wise analysis revealed significantly lower
connectivity in patients with MSA-C involving 40 connections of the
subnetwork (Figure-2). A significant negative correlation was
observed between connectivity of the
thalamus
and total UMSARS scores and UMSARS-II score (Figure-3). At the
edge-level, a few connections showed significant correlations with
the total UMSARS score, and motor severity score (part-II). The
connections involved were between the left cerebellum_8 to vermis_7,
left thalamus to left ventral diencephalon, left-cerebellum_10 to
vermis_4,5, and left-cerebellum_8 to vermis_7. Duration of illness
showed a negative correlation between vermis_6 to vermis_7. Only one
connection from left-cerebellum_4,5 to right-cerebellum_4,5
demonstrated a positive correlation with duration of illness.
Discussion
Our
results provide definitive evidence of damage to connections which
may be causally implicated in the motor features of cerebellar
dysfunction and Parkinsonism observed in MSA-C. Abnormal
global metrics of the motor subnetwork in the MSA-C are suggestive of
impairment in the structural segregation, integration and network
resilience of the motor subnetwork in MSA-C. At a nodal level, we
observed significantly reduced nodal strength in several regions
(Figure 1), indicating poor connectivity with other nodes. In
edge-wise analysis, a higher proportion of abnormal connections
involved nodes within the cerebellum and this observation probably
substantiates the predominance of cerebellar dysfunction in MSA-C.
The observed negative correlation between the UMSARS scores and
thalamus connectivity suggests a definitive involvement of the motor
subnetwork in MSA-C.
Conclusion
Significant
alterations in the structural connectivity of the motor subnetwork at
the global,nodal and edge levels are observed in MSA-C. The higher
degree of abnormality observed in inter and intra-cerebellar
connectivity corroborate with the predominant motor symptom of
cerebellar dysfunction. Future studies exploring the structural
connectivity of non-motor subnetworks are crucial to aid in a better
understanding of the overall disease process in MSA-C.
Acknowledgements
Department
of Science and Technology – Science Education and Research Board
(DSTSERB)(ECR/2016/000808) provided partial funding for setting up
the computing facility.References
-
Fanciulli, A. and G.K. Wenning,
Multiple-system
atrophy. N Engl J
Med, 2015.372(3):
p. 249-63.
-
Gilman, S., et al., Second
consensus statement on the diagnosis of multiple systematrophy.
Neurology, 2008.
71(9):
p. 670-6.
-
Ciolli,
L., et al., An
update on the cerebellar subtype of multiple system
atrophy.Cerebellum
Ataxias, 2014. 1:
p. 14.
-
Barbagallo,
G., et al., Structural
connectivity differences in motor network between tremor-dominant
and nontremor Parkinson's disease. Hum
Brain Mapp, 2017. 38(9):p.
4716-4729.
-
Lewis,
M.M., et al., Differential
involvement of striato- and cerebello-thalamocortical pathways in
tremor- and akinetic/rigid-predominant Parkinson's
disease.Neuroscience,
2011. 177:
p. 230-9.
-
Behrens,
T.E., et al., Probabilistic
diffusion tractography with multiple fibre orientations: What can we
gain? Neuroimage,
2007. 34(1):
p. 144-55.